3 ms·
This is concerning to me, not because I use InfluxDB, but because my company is also a "pure play" OSS vendor. So it's always concerning to see a company fail
by mindcrime 11y ago
This is concerning to me, not because I use InfluxDB, but because my company is also a "pure play" OSS vendor. So it's always concerning to see a company fail to achieve success with the pure-play model, and wind up having to go "open core".
Also, there were some tentative thoughts about using InfluxDB as the main long-term storage backend for Prometheus, but that has become pretty much uninteresting now that clustering support (needed for LTS and durability) is basically cancelled for the open-source version.
True, but consider this: Given that InfluxDB (core) is Open Source, there's nothing to stop somebody else from coming along and building a version with clustering support. Whether that will happen or not is, of course, an open question.
- jrv 11y agoTrue, but a fork is a fork is a fork. It would have to be done very competently (clustering is hard) and maintained long-term, by people who are not even part of InfluxData and thus have a big starting disadvantage in experience and user base. That makes it much less viable, unless there's a huge critical momentum around it.
- bbrazil 11y agoThere's nothing to stop somebody else from coming along and building a version with clustering support. Whether that will happen or not is, of course, an open question. Clustering is really really hard. My personal experience with that class of problem is that it took 3 years to get it production ready, and that was for a simpler problem than what needs to be solved here. The chances of a 3rd party implementing this given that InfluxData plan to have a commercial version seem very low. I'd expect that most companies who want to stay open source will treat this as a standard database that needs client-side sharding and HA (which is the recommend approach - see https://influxdata.com/high-availability/ https://influxdata.com/high-availability/).