2 ms·
I never said anyone should be forced to peel oranges against their will. I actually mentioned the idea because the first couple of comments on the blog post say
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
I never said anyone should be forced to peel oranges against their will. I actually mentioned the idea because the first couple of comments on the blog post say that peeling and wrapping fruit is already a service quietly offered by (most?) grocery-store produce departments; that seems reasonable and praiseworthy, although maybe it's a problem that it's not better-known to the people who need it. There's no need to force anyone to do anything, orange-wise.
> If we really do want the disabled to live better lives we need to make a principled stand and actually pay more tax to fund higher pensions and give them more cash, which they can spend on orange peeling or hawaiian vacations, as they see fit.
That's what I said. Whack asked if I'd support a 1% tax increase to give better support to the disabled, and I said yes. (I'm assuming that support covers a lot more than orange-peeling!)
So it sounds like, as I said, people saw a Marx quote (it's actually from Louis Blanc, Marx only quoted him, but never mind) and immediately assumed that I was agitating for a command economy and five-year plans and whatever. I think that people should hold down a job and pay taxes if they're able, and if they're not able (due to illness, injury, age, physical or mental disability, pregnancy, etc.), they should be able to count on the government/society to take care of them. That's all.
- EdHominem 11y ago> I never said anyone should be forced to peel oranges against their will. Here's what makes it seem like you did: > Making peeling a free service from the produce department, available on request, seems reasonable If a store chooses that as one of their features, it certainly is reasonable for them to do so. Yes. But that's so obvious you wouldn't be saying that..? So the line reads (to me, and I presume, others) as: "It seems like a reasonable thing for us the people to make 'free peeling on request' a thing that produce departments do." ie, an accessibility law. > "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs" is still the best fundamental social principle I can think of. The problem is that needs are infinite and my time is finite. As a loose moral compass it's a nice idea - as a government principle it's nearly slavery.