5 ms·
It's a shame you got downvoted for that, as you make a very good point. This whole trend of making the web browser a poor man's OS is definitely a bit hinky.
by mindcrime 11y ago
It's a shame you got downvoted for that, as you make a very good point. This whole trend of making the web browser a poor man's OS is definitely a bit hinky. I mean, how many layers of abstractions built on top of other (redundant) layers of abstraction really make sense?
This stuff is one reason that, despite the advances associated with Moore's Law, the advent of SSD's, and increasing RAM counts, computers don't feel any faster than they did in 1995. It's ridiculous in a way.
Just to play Devil's Advocate: maybe web browsers should be good at, ya know, browsing and leave the other stuff for something else.
- vectorpush 11y ago> It's a shame you got downvoted for that, as you make a very good point. I think this is because the comment comes off as flippant and snarky. > This stuff is one reason that, despite the advances associated with Moore's Law, the advent of SSD's, and increasing RAM counts, computers don't feel any faster than they did in 1995. It's ridiculous in a way. That statement is ridiculous. I've never heard anyone claim that the computers of today don't "feel" any faster than computers of 20 years ago, but if you feel that way I just don't think you're living in the same universe as those of us who walk around with quad core computers in our pockets. > maybe web browsers should be good at, ya know, browsing and leave the other stuff for something else. Please define "other stuff" and where you draw the line between that and simply "browsing"
- jblow 11y agoAs someone who has been around since before the Web, I can confirm that computers today do not feel any faster... despite the fact that your phone is faster than the fastest computer in the world from that time. In fact I gave a speech about this at Berkeley last week. I think it'll be online pretty soon. So now you have at least heard someone claim this.
- vectorpush 11y ago> As someone who has been around since before the Web, While this is an impressive credential, it's one that I can also claim. > I can confirm that computers today do not feel any faster... despite the fact that your phone is faster than the fastest computer in the world from that time. I appreciate your confirming a subjective feeling based on anecdote, but as someone who was also around in 1995 and has continued to use computers daily since, I'll respectfully provide my own experiences as counter-anecdote to your own. I don't think there's any point in trying to debate our subjective opinions regarding how fast computers feel, but I'll assert that if you sat someone down with a 133mhz P1 desktop with 32MB of ram and a 2ghz i5 with 2GB of ram, 9/10 they'd agree that the 2ghz computer unequivocally feels faster than the 133mhz one.
- jblow 11y agoDude my first professional programming experiences were on a 486/33. Compared to that a P1/133 is pretty darn fast! But as you say, there is not much point debating subjectivity here. It's not like I had the foresight to record benchmarks of how long it took web pages to appear, or to open a window, etc, back in the mid-90s. Edit: How about if I put it this way: If you go back in time to the 90s and tell everyone "20 years from now, we will have a much more advanced web where EVERYONE WILL HAVE A SUPERCOMPUTER IN THEIR POCKET", people would imagine the web would be amazing, and responsive and beautiful, and we would be doing some seriously intricate stuff. Instead ... no, we have a pile of junk that only kind of works, and slowly at that. In terms of potential unreached, the web is kind of a massive failure. (Yes, it is "successful" in the sense that we are able to do a lot with it that we could not 20 years ago, but the mediocre is the enemy of the good, and all that).
- vectorpush 11y ago> people would imagine the web would be amazing, and responsive and beautiful, and we would be doing some seriously intricate stuff. I think this is what happened. Everyone can agree that there are many examples of extreme over-engineering on the modern web, but sites like gmail, facebook, youtube, twitch, google docs etc, by the standards of 1995 are pretty damn amazing, responsive, and beautiful. Concerns about privacy and ads have made us wary of these trends on the web, but from a purely functional perspective, the modern web has achieved incredible technical feats compared to what was possible in 1995. > Instead ... no, we have a pile of junk that only kind of works, and slowly at that. Yes, there is a lot of junk on the web, and yes, it "kind of works", but this is true of all software on all systems. There are plenty of compatibility issues with native software across operating systems, there's also plenty of junk software on the desktop and in mobile app stores. All software is crap and the web is no different, but it isn't especially crappy, it's just that we see a lot more crap on the web because visiting a URL is a lot easier, safer, and more discoverable than executing arbitrary binaries.
- mindcrime 11y agoI think it's a shame you got downvoted as well. Have an upvote on me. As to the rest: I've never heard anyone claim that the computers of today don't "feel" any faster than computers of 20 years ago, Interesting, I find it to be a fairly common refrain. In fact, what I'm saying is basically just a paraphrase of Wirth's Law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth's_law but if you feel that way I just don't think you're living in the same universe as those of us who walk around with quad core computers in our pockets. Well, I walk around with a quad core computer in my pocket as well, and I still stand by that assertion. Please define "other stuff" and where you draw the line between that and simply "browsing" I'll allow that there's some subjectivity there, but when you're talking about a "web application" like, say, Microsoft Outlook online or something, or a programming editor or a CAD program or an image editing program, I can't help but wonder if that stuff should really be done purely "in browser" as opposed to being handed off to another program. OTOH, I understand (some of) the arguments for doing it this way. Having a uniform experience for all clients, the security holes associated with plugins, avoiding the need to deploy software to individual machines, etc. I'd just like to suggest that people spend some time considering if there are other ways to achieve the same end(s) other than continuing to bloat the web browser until it replicates all the functionality offered by the underlying OS.
- jblow 11y ago> Having a uniform experience for all clients An experience that is uniformly slow and uniformly broken a different way on every browser...
- mindcrime 11y agoI largely agree, but the argument is "If we rely on plugins, some users will have the plugin and some won't and since users don't install plugins, not everybody will be able to use our $THING". And it is a somewhat legitimate argument. Whether or not it justifies having the browser subsume everything is, IMO, an open question.
- jblow 11y ago
- justin66 11y ago> I've never heard anyone claim that the computers of today don't "feel" any faster than computers of 20 years ago It's a fairly common observation. What Andy giveth, Bill taketh away, and so on.
- bobajeff 11y agoSomeone else linked to a talk that mentioned removing all the layers in some theoretical architecture called METAL (this is a old talk) basically running asm.js (again talk is old) directly through the Kernel and even removing overhead that Kernels need for making native code safe (such as the Memory Management Unit) and as a result it would run faster than normal native code. https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/the-birth-and-death-of-javascript https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/the-birth-and-death... The major thing to be gained from all this then is software that can run fast but not have to be recompiled for all the different systems and hardware.
- raquo 11y ago> how many layers of abstractions built on top of other (redundant) layers of abstraction really make sense? As many as needed. This is a political problem, not a technical one. OSs don't want to provide one common framework for writing and distributing sandboxed one-click-install write-once-run-anywhere applications. So browsers are solving this problem on their own. Maybe you don't care about this, but users, developers who need to write universal apps, and their marketing managers definitely do.