11 ms·
Climate change skepticism: you're doing it wrong
- rimantas 17y agoI did not know that all skepticism relied on one picture. Actually I never saw that picture before…
- epochwolf 17y agoAccording to the article it was a picture in two british newspapers. Hardly a basis to claim all skeptics are doing this. In fact the claim makes the exact same errors the newspapers did: looking at data out of context. It's two newspapers in the UK that could very possibly be using a single reporter's work and reviewed by editors that don't understand proper research. It's happened before at many other newspapers.
- astine 17y ago"One picture does not a systematic investigation make." No, but it makes a great polemical tool, like polar bears sitting on melting ice and so-forth.
- vixen99 17y agoI hope there are stronger rejoinders in the pipeline than this one. Evidence of crumbling (if not collapse) of stout party comes with the final retort 'And even if it was ....'. Thermometers located adjacent to aircraft parking areas? Sounds eminently sensible! And which serious sceptic is claiming that 'one bad thermometer doesn't mean climate change can be thrown out the window.'?
- Tichy 17y agoJust the other day a story about the percentage of the Netherlands below sea levels being wrong in some article got a lot of upvotes on hacker news...
- CapitalistCartr 17y agoYeah this is what is commonly known as a straw man argument. Actual climate skepticism is at least as complex as climate theory, and one newspaper's incompetence in reporting isn't even news. If anything, this would make a good anecdote regarding current mainstream press' sloppy reporting.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoThis reminded me of the "one way hash" rhetorical technique. I'd actually forgotten that the term was coined in relation to climate change discussions. http://www.juliansanchez.com/2009/04/06/climate-change-and-argumentative-fallacies/ http://www.juliansanchez.com/2009/04/06/climate-change-and-a...
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoJohn, I have a bit of cognitive dissonance going on here. I scanned this and have no idea what you're trying to do. Is it to take one picture used by some skeptics and try to base an entire case of what climate science is like? If so, that's clearly using a straw man argument. Of course, in lots of dimensions climate change is a political/religious discussion, and you've every right to use all sorts of rhetorical tools to persuade us. But since your point is about science, logic, and reasoning, why the heavy-handed format? You're actually making the case that you're not so good at the science end of things, and that certainly can't be what you wanted, right?
- jgrahamc 17y agoProbably not one of my best blog posts, I was just mad about the way in which two newspapers in the UK have reported the Rome airport situation as part of larger stories about how climate change apparently isn't happening.
- epochwolf 17y agoI just find it ironic that you're making the same error in judgement that the newspapers did.
- moron4hire 17y ago8% of weather stations are rated as "poor" (>= 2C error) and 61% of stations are rated as "worst" (>= 5C error). It's not just "one bad thermometer". It's the vast majority of thermometers that are bad. http://www.surfacestations.org/ http://www.surfacestations.org/
- jgrahamc 17y agoI agree that those are the claims made by Surface Stations. Do you know if their raw data is available for download? I see their report on what they are doing, but I would be great to see the raw, uninterpreted data about their findings.
- moron4hire 17y agoThey're hidden in an obscure, non-standard UI element known as the "left side bar menu", with cryptically named links "Online Database" and "Resources". http://gallery.surfacestations.org/main.php http://gallery.surfacestations.org/main.php http://www.surfacestations.org/resources.htm http://www.surfacestations.org/resources.htm
- jgrahamc 17y agoI've looked at those pages and the Gallery allows me to zoom into pictures of any individual station and look at scanned reports of the status. But what I was asking for was something different. The project is apparently generating data which allows them to make specific claims about the state of each station and product roll-up statistics. I imagine somewhere there's a database or spreadsheet with that information in it. I can't find that for download anywhere, can you?
- moron4hire 17y agoI'm sure you could request it
- jgrahamc 17y ago
- mml 17y agoyeah, um, but they've recorded a couple of hundred even worse situations (next to ac exhaust, in asphalt lots etc)
- azgolfer 17y agoI would say it's the proponents that are doing it wrong. The supposedly independent and objective inquiry into the climategate scandal has already had one member forced to resign (the editor of Nature, btw) http://climateaudit.org/2010/02/11/the-team-that-cant-shoot-straight/ http://climateaudit.org/2010/02/11/the-team-that-cant-shoot-... and now another member looks very questionable http://climateaudit.org/2010/02/15/more-tricks-from-boulton-and-the-hapless-muir-russell/ http://climateaudit.org/2010/02/15/more-tricks-from-boulton-...