7 ms·
I think economics needs a lot more of this. Economists are rational people, by and large, but a lot of them have very perverse incentives. I think we could see
by jdietrich 17y ago
I think economics needs a lot more of this. Economists are rational people, by and large, but a lot of them have very perverse incentives. I think we could see a minor revolution in economic forecasting if we gave stronger incentives for accuracy and vice versa.
- samh 17y agoAbsolutely. Every time I see the senior economist from the Westpac bank being interviewed on the television I think : 1 - Why do they keep interviewing him about the future but never talk about how accurate he was in the past. 2 - He is deliberately couching everything he says in 'weasel words' so as to never risk being wrong. But he wears a suit, has a position of authority and looks like he should know what he is talking about, that seems to be all they want. Much of the world is a confidence trick.
- mos1 17y ago2 - He is deliberately couching everything he says in 'weasel words' so as to never risk being wrong. This is often because he has to grossly simplify what his actual research has said in order for it to be consumable by a mass audience. The papers may spell out certain prerequisites and gotchas quite explicitly, but in a TV interview, that turns into a vague-sounding "it depends". 1 - Why do they keep interviewing him about the future but never talk about how accurate he was in the past. I've often wished that people who made predictions for a living were forced to assign probabilities to their statements, and give some clear definition, so we could keep score.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoOne thing we could do would be to create prediction markets, which are just a more systematic way of allowing people to make bets on policy outcomes. This way, if an economist doesn't (literally) put his money where his mouth is, you know not to trust him. Of course, in the US, this would require legalizing gambling. Unfortunately, our backwards approach to securities markets even discourage speculation except as a way to provide liquidity for hedging. [disclaimer: I'm currently working at a prediction market startup.]