3 ms·
I am getting a little tired of the "F-35 is bad" headlines. There should be more context that tells us how common such problems are in general. I remember liste
by maxxxxx 11y ago
I am getting a little tired of the "F-35 is bad" headlines. There should be more context that tells us how common such problems are in general. I remember listening to a podcast where they said that SR-71 pilots had to restart their engine every so often. Same for the Concorde. Sounds really bad but neither of these problems hurt the airplanes' usability and were not really a problem.
I firmly believe that military procurement is a mess but the discussion reminds me of the political discussion where Republicans jump on anything that goes wrong under Democrats and vice versa.
- Jtsummers 11y agoTo be fair, the SR-71 was a highly specialized, and ultimately, highly experimental aircraft at its time. The Concorde was similar. Only a few were ever made, and they were never expected to be the ubiquitous aircraft of their time or even their type (reconnaissance and passenger transport). The F-35 is intended to replace several aircraft models which currently satisfy more specialized roles. It was intended to be the ubiquitous (in various configurations) fighter aircraft for the US military (and some allies). This problem may not be the worst of its issues, it may not even be a major issue or really (from the pilots' perspective) an issue at all since similar reboots (but less frequent) are the norm for them in other aircraft. But many other issues are demonstrating, and the reduced production numbers and increased production and development costs reveal, that there are numerous problems with this project in particular. It shows failings within the US political structure (that's essentially forced this project to continue), DoD procurement (that allowed many of these issues to occur initially), defense contractor procedures (LM, IIRC, doubling or tripling the number of engineers on the software side to "speed things up"). Really, it's going to be a classic for future engineers, computer scientists, MBAs and others to study. So I guess that's a good thing.
- maxxxxx 11y agoI totally agree that the F-35 project is a mess. But I would like to see a real analysis of the problems and not just jumping on any problem that sounds bad on the surface. Maybe a hard reboot is a problem, maybe not. I don't know.
- Jtsummers 11y agohttp://www.dote.osd.mil/pub/reports/FY2015/pdf/dod/2015f35jsf.pdf http://www.dote.osd.mil/pub/reports/FY2015/pdf/dod/2015f35js... Haven't read it all, but started reading it. At least this is more "from the horse's mouth" rather than outside commentary like the Ars article.
- mikeash 11y agoThe SR-71 was a bit more exciting than just restarting the engine. The problem there was actually an inlet unstart. Those big spikes at the front of the engines could move, and had to be adjusted to just the right location to direct the shock waves properly so the engine proper got nice airflow. Naturally, this was all done automatically, but the electronics weren't perfect. Sometimes they'd get too far out of adjustment, and the shock wave would blow out. This was apparently a pretty violent event, with a loud bang from the engine, often accompanied by another loud bang as the crew's helmets were slammed against the side of the cockpit. I believe that the SR-71's control systems were eventually upgraded to where this didn't happen anymore, or was very rare, but it was apparently somewhat common for a while. Some discussion here, along with bonus discussion of the F-35's inlet: http://www.airspacemag.com/military-aviation/how-things-work-supersonic-inlets-35428453/?no-ist http://www.airspacemag.com/military-aviation/how-things-work... None of this affects your overall point, I just thought it was a fun thing to elaborate on a bit. I think you're on to something with this. It sure seems like the F-35 is not a particularly good airplane, but that's mainly because of cost and capabilities. Stuff like this does sound like piling on, rather than any substantive criticism.
- engi_nerd 11y agoThis particular issue is not really worthy of being reported in the media. Yes, there are radar problems that require it to be rebooted. But the issues have been identified and a fix is in work and will be rolled out soon. This story is a non-starter.