2 ms·
Pitch it as a creativity game rather than a logic game. I mean, it's a little bit of both, right?
by kqr 11y ago
Pitch it as a creativity game rather than a logic game. I mean, it's a little bit of both, right?
- Radim 11y agoIt's a creative game only to the degree your logic (reading) is not strong enough :) I mean, deep down, Go is a perfect-information-zero-sum-discrete-2-player game. I think a more successful pitch is showing that the strategies and skills coming from Go (human or robot) can be useful outside the game, as I argue here: http://rare-technologies.com/go_games_life/ http://rare-technologies.com/go_games_life/
- jholman 11y agoTo me, "creative" is not the right word. Maybe try "intuitive". As Radim says, of course, the intuition is only relevant when logic fails. However, no computer, including AlphaGo, has sufficient processing power to take the logic-only approach to the, uh, logical extreme (more board states than atoms in the universe, etc etc). So both humans and computers play by a combination of logic and intuition. Surely Lee Sedol must be incredibly good at both. Perhaps AlphaGo is better than Lee Sedol at the logic part (or perhaps not, but just suppose for the sake of argument). In this light, what is interesting is that AlphaGo is sufficiently good at intuition, a domain we might have considered uniquely human[0], to complement its ferocious logical power. [0] I find it foolish to consider anything uniquely human, but a humanist essentialist might make such a claim.
- Jach 11y agoThe other interesting bit is the combination, the intuition guiding (and evaluating the results of) the logical searching. I'm still holding out for the discovery of a proof of winning strategy like other combinatorial games. That to me is the logical extreme, not magic evaluation of all states. There are two interesting books on analyzing Go with combinatorial game theory, they found a neat system of scoring in the endgame and can create example boards with one best move that can be found by mechanically applying their system but stumps 9p players (who use whatever systems).