3 ms·
The "I'm not an American" question: Why does the IRS allow you to write off mortgage interest? That seems like a lot of tax lost for not much benefit to the gov
by petercooper 17y ago
The "I'm not an American" question: Why does the IRS allow you to write off mortgage interest? That seems like a lot of tax lost for not much benefit to the government. Was it enacted to boost property ownership or something?
- patio11 17y agoThe same story as every other one-off in the tax code: it was slipped in to placate an interest group who would monetarily benefit from the deduction, on the theory that the deduction rewards socially valuable behavior. (The official position of the American government for over a generation now has been that increasing home ownership is, ipso facto, socially desirable. It is a cornerstone of the "American Dream" -- our consensus idealized version of an idyllic middle class existence. ) Mortgage interest is a bit different than other one-off tax code hacks in that the group which benefits is much, much larger than typical. It is also essentially impossible to repeal, as the mortgage interest deduction essentially makes mortgages cheaper which makes property values higher, so repealing it would have the immediate consequence of making half the country poorer and also breaking their monthly budgets in an extraordinarily visible fashion. A similar middle-class entitlement is the essentially limitless access to education loans. That also has some negative consequences (it underwrites the continual tuition inflation in higher education) and will also never be meaningfully reigned in. [Edited to add: A common misconception, even among Americans, is that the IRS sets tax policy. The IRS does not set tax policy. Congress does, via legislation. The IRS just implements Congress' directives -- however vague, contradictory, and ill-advised they may be. My apologies if you already knew this and were just being imprecise in language.]
- whatusername 17y agoIt's quite interesting in Australia - Home mortgage interest is not deducted but Investment Property interest is considered a business expense and is thus deductible. (Which makes sense to a degree - purchasing an income-generating asset is deductible for any other business, why not in RE).
- petercooper 17y agoSame in the UK. However, there's a loophole, of sorts, that lets you claim a percentage of your mortgage interest in the UK if one room or area of the property is dedicated to your business.
- petercooper 17y agoThe IRS does not set tax policy. Congress does, via legislation. [..] My apologies if you already knew this and were just being imprecise in language. It's roughly the same here in the UK (though the tax man can choose to "interpret" the laws in his own special way) but I was being more pragmatic than accurate - the tax authorities are the "face" behind these sorts of policies, even if the law makers came up with them :-)