4 ms·
Google could send people to places that are contrary to the user's interest, but that's essentially deliberately decreasing the quality of one of their products
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
Google could send people to places that are contrary to the user's interest, but that's essentially deliberately decreasing the quality of one of their products so I'm not that worried about it. If they do it's a (big) market opportunity for someone else.
I would go even farther: I'm not particularly worried about individual interests at all, on any subject. The Internet is very good at exposing them.
I am much more concerned with bad classes of actors than bad actors. We see many ways in which competition breaks down because entire classes of people benefit from working in synchrony. The classic example is politicians: crooked elections mean longer terms which benefits basically all of them.
The other classic example is the capital class. If everyone in the capital class plays by he rules of property then they can exploit the labor class. Once you're in the capital class there are few reasons to compete with private property. Social pressure mostly neuters whatever capital class activists might try to keep working.
It's these class barriers that we should be worried about. But new weapons (like search engines) and new villains (like Islam) make much better news stories.
- tdaltonc 11y agoIt's not trivial to ascertain what a users "interests" are. And I think that's the debate here. Google optimization algorithms are an embodiment of a value system, and maybe I don't agree with it. McDonalds also gives people what they want, but only in a very narrow sense of 'want'.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoIt doesn't really matter if it's trivial. It's in Google's interest to do it so it tends to happen. McDonalds isn't really uniquely bad. Burger King, Jack in the Box, et al are basically the same. They are a perfect example of what I described: a class of actors to whom there is benefit to acting in concert against the best interests of consumers.