3 ms·
>> In case you're not aware, AlphaGo's key component is based on the same type of Deepmind system that learned to play dozens of Atari games, to superhuman leve
by YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago
>> In case you're not aware, AlphaGo's key component is based on the same type of Deepmind system that learned to play dozens of Atari games, to superhuman levels, by watching the pixels, without any programmatic adaptation to the particular Atari game.
The Atari-playing AI watched the pixels indeed, but it was also given a set of actions to choose from and more importantly, a reward representing the change in the game score.
That means it wasn't able to learn the significance of the score on its own, or to generalise from the significance of the changing score in one game, to another.
It also played Atari games, that _have_ scores, so it would have been completely useless in situations where there is no score, or a clear win/loss situation.
AlphaGo is also similarly specialised to play Go. As is machine learning in general: someone has to tell the algorithm what it needs to learn, either through data engineering, or reward functions etc. A general AI would learn what is important on its own, like humans do, so machine learning has not yet shown that it can develop into AGI.
- Houshalter 11y agoI think you are confusing utility functions with intelligence. All AIs need utility functions. An AI without a utility function would just do nothing. It would have no reason to beat Atari games, because it wouldn't get any reward for doing so. Even humans have utility functions. For example, we get rewards for having sex, or eating food, or just making social relationships with other humans. Or we have negative reinforcement from pain, and getting hurt, or getting rejected socially. You can come up with more complicated utility functions. Like instead of beating the game, it's goal could be to explore as much of the game as possible. To discover novel things in the game. Kind of like a sense of boredom or novelty that humans have. But in the end it's still just a utility function, it doesn't change how the algorithm itself works to achieve it. AGI is entirely agnostic to the utility function.
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> I think you are confusing utility functions with intelligence. No, what I'm really saying is that you can't have an autonomous agent that needs to be told what to do all the time. In machine learning, we train algorithms by giving them examples of what we want them to learn, so basically we tell them what to learn. And if we want them to learn something new, we have to train them again, on new data. Well, that's not conducive to autonomous or "general" intelligence. There may be any number of tasks that your "general" AI will need to perform competently at. What's it gonna do? Come back to you and cry every time it fails at something? So then you have a perpetual child AI that will never stand on its own two feet as an adult, because there's always something new for it to learn. Happy little AI, for sure, but not very useful and not very "general". Except for a general nuisance, maybe. Edit: I'm saying that machine learning can't possibly lead to general AI, because it's crap at learning useful things on its own.
- Houshalter 11y agoMachine learning doesn't "need to be told what to do all the time". No one told alphaGo what strategies were the best. It figured that out on it's own, by playing against itself. There is also unsupervised and semi-supervised learning, which can take advantage of unlabelled data. Even supervised learning can work really well on weakly labelled data. E.g. taking pictures from the internet and using the words that occur next to them as labels. As opposed to hiring a person to manually label all of them. I don't know what situation you are imagining that would make the AI "come back and cry". You will need to give an example.
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> Machine learning doesn't "need to be told what to do all the time". No one told alphaGo what strategies were the best. Of course they did. They trained it with examples of Go games and they also programmed it with a reward function that led it to select the winning games. Otherwise, it wouldn't have learned anything useful. >> There is also unsupervised and semi-supervised learning, which can take advantage of unlabelled data. Sure, but unsupervised learning is useless for learning specific behaviours. You use it for feature discovery and data exploration. As to semi-supervised learning, it's "semi" supervised: it learns its own features, then you train it with labels so that it learns a mapping from those features it discovered to the classes you want it to output. >> I don't know what situation you are imagining that would make the AI "come back and cry" That was an instance of humour [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humour
- Houshalter 11y ago>Of course they did. They trained it with examples of Go games and they also programmed it with a reward function that led it to select the winning games. Otherwise, it wouldn't have learned anything useful. Yes, but it doesn't need to be trained with examples of Go games. It helps a lot, but it isn't 100% necessary. It can learn to play entirely through self play. The atari games were entirely self play. As for having a reward function for winning games, of course that is necessary. Without a reward function, any AI would cease to function. That's true even of humans. All agents need reward functions. See my original comment. >That was an instance of humour Yes I know what humour is lel. I asked you for a specific example where you think this would matter. Where your kind of AI would do better than a reinforcement learning AI.