14 ms·
Pentagon admits it has deployed military spy drones over the U.S
- cgriswald 11y ago> "Sometimes, new technology changes so rapidly that existing law no longer fit what people think are appropriate," Stanley said. Sometimes, maybe. I'd argue rarely. I don't see much difference between an unmanned drone and an unmanned satellite or a manned helicopter in terms of applicable law. Believing that a new law is needed because computers/drones/robots/AI/whatever now exist can lead to bad laws, or laws that are out-of-balance in terms of punishment. (i.e., commit a crime - 5 years. commit the same crime WITH A COMPUTER - 10 years) > "It's important to remember that the American people do find this to be a very, very sensitive topic." I think the media finds this to be an eyeball-grabbing topic, but AFAICT, the American people do not care much about it.
- fosco 11y agoI like your communication here. I would love to explore this in a separate discussion at first glance I would say certain crimes are not possible at magnitude without a computer or technology to assist. With extreme simplification I consider computers to be a tool to increase productivity. With that said, I will agree, the same exact crime in type and magnitude should have the same punishment, not altered.
- privong 11y ago> Sometimes, maybe. I'd argue rarely. I don't see much difference between an unmanned drone and an unmanned satellite or a manned helicopter in terms of applicable law. I think the important distinction is police vs millitary, not drone vs satellite vs helicopter. As @protomyth pointed out, there is existing law (Posse Comitatus Act) which may prohibit such things. The article does say that the drone flights were done in accordance with existing laws. But, given the propensity for the FBI to flaunt laws and mislead the public about doing so, I'm not sure how much I trust that statement in the article. > Believing that a new law is needed because computers/drones/robots/AI/whatever now exist can lead to bad laws, or laws that are out-of-balance in terms of punishment. (i.e., commit a crime - 5 years. commit the same crime WITH A COMPUTER - 10 years) I agree with this. I don't think new laws should necessarily be specifically created for this. At any rate, it seems like the Posse Comitatus Act should cover this already.
- merpnderp 11y agoUsing the military against US citizens is such a horrendous thought, that it's explicitly outlawed. And those drones are easily armed, so if you want a comparison, this isn't like a manned helicopter. It's like a manned Apache helicopter, that just happens to not have a complement of Hellfire and 70mm rockets, patrolling the US skies. People would freak out if they looked up and saw that doing law enforcement duties.
- freeone3000 11y agoYou mean like the https://tankandafvnews.files.wordpress.com/2015/11/7.jpg https://tankandafvnews.files.wordpress.com/2015/11/7.jpg M113s used by sheriffs?
- pc86 11y agoThere is a difference between a military operation on US soil and civilian law enforcement using military hardware.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThere's a difference in who pulls the trigger. Anything else?
- walshemj 11y agoA lot more training and stricter rules of engagement - personally id prefer seal team 6 for dealing with a mass shooting incident ala Paris rather than which ever Podunk police swat team happens to be local.
- ohitsdom 11y agoAnd Americans have been extremely upset over the militarization of our police (much of which gained public exposure after Ferguson). Obama talked about it fairly regularly since then, going so far as to ban sales. http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2015/05/18/obama-police-military-equipment-sales-new-jersey/27521793/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2015/05/18/obama...
- benologist 11y agoLaws, and democracy, should be evolving just like we do because our ancestors - 100s of years ago, even 10s of years ago - simply did not come up with timeless solutions to much stuff any more than the people who wrote the bible did a couple thousand years before them. Some of the things we once defined as just we now consider to be heinous human rights violations that only occur in the worst corners of the world - slavery, inequality etc. Some laws are commonly considered out of date and failing today's society - drugs, mass-incarceration, copyright, patents, marriage.
- protomyth 11y agoWhy, yes, they used one to find a cattle rustler in ND http://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelpeck/2014/01/27/predator-drone-sends-north-dakota-man-to-jail/#6f1f45735853 http://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelpeck/2014/01/27/predator-... I still believe this should have illegal as they had no warrant and it violates the Posse Comitatus Act.
- jngreenlee 11y agoNot illegal in this case, because the Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) is a department of the Department of Homeland Security, is not covered by the Posse Comitatus Act. Although the CBP is an armed service, it has a federal regulatory agency mission. The Act only specifically applies to the United States Army and, as amended in 1956, the United States Air Force.
- protomyth 11y agoCBP in name, but its serviced and housed at the Air Force base. Its still outside their mission (CBP does not have a charter to deal with cattle rustlers). Also, the fact Customs and Border Patrol is doing anything away from the border (that 100 mile thing is pure BS) is still troubling.
- fosco 11y agoit is Customs and Border Protection, their responsibilities are a lot more than you think. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Customs_and_Border_Protection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Customs_and_Border_Protec... http://www.cbp.gov/about http://www.cbp.gov/about
- protomyth 11y agoEvery one of their powers and directives is worded against foreign threats, not people inside the border. The mission creep is similar to how anti-terrorist laws are used for drug enforcement.
- beau26 11y agoIt's shameful that (a) it took a freedom of information request to make this information public. (b) the Pentagon did it's own internal report and found that there was no wrongdoing. (c) that nobody in the government is going to hold these clowns responsible or create any sort of legitimate process for determining whether these flights were legal or not.
- jngreenlee 11y agoLook I don't love these ether, but: "A senior policy analyst for the ACLU, Jay Stanley, said it is good news no legal violations were found" "the Pentagon established interim guidance in 2006 governing when and whether the unmanned aircraft could be used domestically. The interim policy allowed spy drones to be used for homeland defense purposes in the U.S. and to assist civil authorities."
- olivermarks 11y agoIf you believe that you'll believe anything...
- ceejayoz 11y agoThe ACLU doesn't tend to toe the government's line. In general, them saying "looks legit" is a pretty good sign.
- gr3yh47 11y ago>and to assist civil authorities. disgusting how broad that is, almost anything could be under that umbrella
- VLM 11y agoThere's could be, which is of course anything, and is known to be, which AFAIK is only JSOC aka the folks in charge of seal team 6 and delta force, lately of the drone attacks in the middle east, etc. The Sec Defense can make available for "expert advice" and "training" and stuff like that, and that's what JSOC operates under. AFAIK they're the only army command running under those rules on a continuous basis. Note that the Army does bust active duty MPs for doing things off base. Another rarely understood part of the Posse Comitatus act is a state governor can do anything he wants inside his own state with NG / ANG troops. Its only when they're federalized or operating outside their state that they can't enforce laws. NG troops can "pretty much" do anything their governor orders them to do within their state borders. The active, reserve, and guard components are at least sometimes deeply intermeshed. Would not surprise me for a guard pilot to casually be called an "army dude" by a journalist with no military experience (aka all of them)
- jngreenlee 11y agoThere's a lot of talk about the Posse Comitatus Act[0]. The real distinction is in "intent of the mission". A mission that is: A)Conducted by United States Army or the United States Air Force, and B)Conducted to enforce domestic policies within the United States Would be in violation of the Posse Comitatus Act. However, there is disagreement over whether this language may apply to troops used in an advisory, support, disaster response, or other homeland defense role, as opposed to domestic law enforcement.[1] [0]http://legisworks.org/sal/20/stats/STATUTE-20-Pg152.pdf http://legisworks.org/sal/20/stats/STATUTE-20-Pg152.pdf [1]https://www.jagcnet.army.mil/DOCLIBS/MILITARYLAWREVIEW.NSF/20a66345129fe3d885256e5b00571830/47c2b664085060fc85256e5b00576e6e/$FILE/Volume175Felicetti.pdf https://www.jagcnet.army.mil/DOCLIBS/MILITARYLAWREVIEW.NSF/2...
- 50uth 11y agoWhen Donald Trump is running for president, I don't think anything could surprise me anymore. Sad times America!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- EasyTiger_ 11y agoNext come drone attacks on US citizens? And who is going to stop them, now that they can do anything they want in the name of terrorism.
- chippy 11y agoThey have already done this with Anwar al-Awlaki, but in this case it was not on US soil http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jun/23/us-justification-drone-killing-american-citizen-awlaki http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jun/23/us-justificatio...
- acjohnson55 11y agoNot to mention, his son, who was also a US citizen and not generally thought to have been a radical.
- merpnderp 11y agoThe guy was a very bad person according to his indictments. A judge signed off on it as long as there was no way to arrest and try him, and given it was Yemen, there wasn't. Now his son on the other hand is extremely questionable and smacks of revenge. http://www.latimes.com/nation/nationnow/la-na-nn-drone-memo-awlaki-20140623-story.html http://www.latimes.com/nation/nationnow/la-na-nn-drone-memo-...
- unchocked 11y agoWhile I share your apparent concern for civil liberties, the assumption that we're likely to see armed drone strikes on US soil is hyperbolic and rooted in misapprehension of why the state uses drone strikes abroad. Drone strikes are used as a replacement for manned air strikes, which in turn are used when a target is too isolated to engage with ground forces. The reason that we're not going to see drone strikes on US soil is the same reason we don't see air strikes on US soil: you can deploy SWAT teams on US soil.
- arca_vorago 11y agoThe actual danger from militarized drones actually comes not from "strikes", in the sense that the military uses them (mostly from large predator style UAVs), but in the militarization of police as it relates to using drones. In this case I am mostly seeing gas powered helo-uav's with armaments attached, and the laws are quickly being passed to dot the i's and cross the t's for LE. http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/08/27/435301160/north-dakota-legalizes-armed-police-drones http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/08/27/435301160/... So you are correct in that we won't see hellfire missles deployed on US ground, but rather small arms on wings... which is almost scarier to me simply because a hellfire would raise eyebrows, but a news snippet of using a armed drone to engage a $villan is sure to become normalized far too quickly.
- jameslk 11y agoIt seems hypocritical to assume this is any worse than having these drones flying over other countries, sometimes without their consent.
- ethanbond 11y ago"Worse" is subjective. "Legal" is quite a bit less so – although not totally objective even then.
- jameslk 11y agoI guess what I was trying to say is that if it's considered illegal to fly these drones over the US because it violates constitutional rights, consider why that would be and then compare that with the reasoning for allowing it to happen to other citizens of other nations. What exactly is the difference other than the laws? If the goal of these drones is to spy on terrorists, then isn't it possible that terrorists exist in the US too? If we shouldn't have drones spying on US citizens because it violates our privacy, then shouldn't other citizens of other nations have privacy too? Maybe it's not so bad (or illegal?) if these drones fly over some middle eastern nation, but what if we started flying them over some western nation like the UK, or Germany (potentially without their consent). Is it still okay then?
- jacquesm 11y agoThe term you are looking for is 'airspace violation'. Violating another countries airspace like that is a dangerous game, in some cases leading to planes being shot down. Now with drones the pilots life are not at risk so countries will have a lower barrier to try this but eventually the country that you this on might retaliate. Wars have started over less in history.
- ohitsdom 11y agoPosse Comitatus Act: severely limits military operations domestically. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posse_Comitatus_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posse_Comitatus_Act
- l3m0ndr0p 11y agoThose people that are responsible for this activity should be brought before a court and tried for treason.
- sparky_z 11y agoAccording to the article (which is all I have to go on) the ACLU reviewed each incident and said they were all legal. Lobby to change the law if you like, but you can't put someone on trial for taking legal actions you find distasteful.
- zzz157 11y agoAwesome, another post downplaying the severity of the issue. Why don't YOU lobby to change the law? Right, because I guess you're fine with the surveillance state.
- Zhenya 11y agoI wonder who mayor genius is: One case in which an unnamed mayor asked the Marine Corps to use a drone to find potholes in the mayor's city.
- hyperliner 11y agoYou did not include the best part: to find potholes in the mayor's city
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoThat sounds like Chicago, certainly, though you don't need aerial surveillance to find those, they're everywhere.
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoLooks like he did include that; did you scroll horizontally? HN does that to some types of text and I can't remember why but it's quite annoying.
- gohrt 11y agoInput text indented 4-spaces is "PRE" formatted and HN won't line-wrap it.
- rcraft 11y agoTotal shot in the dark, but perhaps Chicago mayor Rahm Emmanuel due to his ties to the White House (former Obama chief of staff). What other mayors would even know this type of opportunity existed?!
- cbanek 11y agoA couple of weeks ago, I was taking in some scenery around Creech AFB, North of Las Vegas. While there, I saw a Predator (although it might have been a MQ-9 Reaper) being launched from the airstrip. It looked like a giant model aircraft getting launched when the wind hit it. Pretty cool at the time, although after reading this, I hope it was just a training mission over some non-existent Nevada AFB...
- laxatives 11y agoI'm definitely no expert, but I'm almost certain I saw low flying drones around Dulles Airport in VA (about an hour from DC) near where I lived in 2005-2009.
- jallmann 11y ago> an unnamed mayor asked the Marine Corps to use a drone to find potholes in the mayor's city Let's play a guessing game! San Diego? We've got Miramar and Camp Pendleton here, along with crumbling infrastructure and terrible potholes. Although the city certainly doesn't need help finding potholes around here... Using drones for this kind of thing actually makes a lot of sense, although not a $20 million militarized Predator.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoA bit overkill no? Could you not just partner with Google Maps and use the phone accelerometer to detect potholes?
- Zigurd 11y agoThere are both crowdsourced and fleet-oriented apps and systems to do that, and anyone in charge of a bid would know this within 5 minutes of googling the topic from a cold start. It is such a lame excuse I'm inclined to call BS and think it's a cover story.
- SocksCanClose 11y agocould also use non-military-grade satellite photos and this technique: www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA458753
- madaxe_again 11y agoIt's either a cover or the kind of propaganda gig that you see in military dictatorships - "Troops rescue cat from tree!" "Paratroopers deployed to give children candy!" "Death squad visits old people's home with cake!"
- ErikAugust 11y agoYou nailed it. Of course it's a cover story. It's USA Today - the newspaper they sell at McDonald's.
- jallmann 11y ago
- pinaceae 11y agoNow you know how it feels. /signed by the rest of the world.
- m23khan 11y agoPakistan says Hi!
- madaxe_again 11y agoLegal != right.
- nerdcity 11y ago>any use of military drones for civil authorities had to be approved by the Secretary of Defense Gee, what oversight. I'm sure they'll be denying approvals left and right.
- shmerl 11y agoReminds me this: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20121205/21484221251/nyc-artists-satirizes-law-enforcement-drone-program-gets-book-thrown-him-nypd.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20121205/21484221251/nyc-a...
- mmaunder 11y agoIt will take a few years, but drone use will trickle down from the military into federal and local enforcement branches. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militarization_of_police https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militarization_of_police I'm curious about the flight plan approval and filing process they go through with the FAA. Also wondering if the flights show up on the 5 minute delayed ASDI API: http://www.fly.faa.gov/ASDI/asdi.html http://www.fly.faa.gov/ASDI/asdi.html And if the drones carry ADS-B transceivers and if they show up on other transceivers during flight. (Which would make them visible/trackable to anyone ground or air based that is listening) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_dependent_surveillance_%E2%80%93_broadcast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_dependent_surveillan...
- gozur88 11y agoThe FBI and DEA (at least) already use drones. Personally, from a law enforcement perspective I don't see the big difference between drones and manned aircraft. What really matters is what kind of sensors are on the aircraft and what they do with the data.
- __jal 11y agoI see a difference. Not today, because military drones (as far as I know) are still human-piloted. But that won't last. And then... It is the same difference as exists between automatic license plate readers and people standing on a corner with a pad and paper. I realize that a certain mindset (active in legal circles, but not exclusively so) that doesn't see that capabilities end up swallowing the original tradeoffs in some contexts. Put a different way, you're right. There's no capability difference. Lower cost and automation will simply allow much, much more of the same. Like how automatic weapons offer no capability difference over a single shot rifle - they just do the same thing faster. Hm...
- gozur88 11y agoMaybe eventually. Right now it's still cheaper to put a guy up there in a Cessna.
- spdustin 11y agoIt's not just drones. Law Enforcement often flies surveillance flights, circling over locations of interest. These planes often have thermal/visual imaging video cameras and, according to some stories, may also be carrying other tracking or signal interception hardware (think Stingray). HN user jjwiseman [0] scooped most of the press about this. You can locate such "interesting" flights right now, using your browser. Just open up ADSB Exchange Virtual Radar [1], which doesn't filter out flights with certain squawk codes like other online virtual radar sites do. If you do, select "Menu" from the map (with the gear icon), then "Options". Select the "Filter" tab, select to "Enable filters", select "Interesting" from the dropdown listbox, and select "Add Filter". Now you can zoom out over the country, and see all the "interesting" flights using the table on the left. Note any flights with the "LE" or "FBI" or "DHS" user tag. Right now, as I write this, an FBI-owned aircraft is circling over the Norwood/Bronx area of NYC [2], tail number N912EX, registered to OBR Leasing (one of the "shells" that the US Gov't uses for registering its law enforcement aircraft), as mentioned in an AP story last summer [3] [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=jjwiseman https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=jjwiseman [1]: http://www.adsbexchange.com http://www.adsbexchange.com, select "Currently Tracking [number] Aircraft on upper-right" [2]: http://i.imgur.com/EUYqx98.png http://i.imgur.com/EUYqx98.png [3]: http://bigstory.ap.org/article/4b3f220e33b64123a3909c60845da045/fbi-behind-mysterious-surveillance-aircraft-over-us-cities http://bigstory.ap.org/article/4b3f220e33b64123a3909c60845da... Edit: Another one, flying around NW Los Angeles, right now: http://i.imgur.com/PwRpqRe.png http://i.imgur.com/PwRpqRe.png Edit2: Any aircraft squawking transponder beacon codes between 4401-4433 are engaged in law enforcement operations. More on the various squawk codes reserved by US Gov't operations can be found here (pdf link): http://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Order/FINAL_Order_7110_66E_NBCAP.pdf http://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Order/FINAL_Order_7...
- xredlinexx1 11y agoInteresting. There is one over northwest LA as well.
- jjwiseman 11y agoThat's N404KR, which over the past year has flown over Los Angeles on average one day in five. It's one of the top 10 planes I receive transponder pings from, in frequency.
- tokenadult 11y agoFrom the article: "The Pentagon has publicly posted at least a partial list of the drone missions that have flown in non-military airspace over the United States and explains the use of the aircraft. The site lists nine missions flown between 2011 and 2016, largely to assist with search and rescue, floods, fires or National Guard exercises. "A senior policy analyst for the ACLU, Jay Stanley, said it is good news no legal violations were found, yet the technology is so advanced that it's possible laws may require revision." This sounds a lot less dramatic than the article headline, but it's good that this is being reported and discussed publicly.
- cheath 11y agoI'm pretty sensitive to these things. That said, if you look at the partial list provided (granted this was potentially cherry picked), we're looking primarily at disaster awareness stuff. Flooding, wild fires, and search & rescue. Not spying. Military resources, such as The National Guard, get called up for disaster relief all of the time. I think I'd rather drones helping people in these scenarios than what they're primarily used for.
- Vexs 11y agoI agree. Military tech is the best tech, if it can spot a terrorist in a bush than it can, and should be used to find victims of natural disasters. Also, I don't think UAVs are the best option for mass surveillance. I mean, there's cameras on every corner, phones in every pocket, etc. There's enough cameras to spy on people, you don't need to stick a very expensive drone that will last only a couple hours/days and not be able to peek in houses as well as someone's webcam. I'm not sure how I feel about this bit though. > an unnamed mayor asked the Marine Corps to use a drone to find potholes in the mayor's city I mean. Is it helpful? Yes. Is it a really good way to find potentially dangerous potholes? Probably. It just seems... excessive.
- sonoffett 11y ago> I don't think UAVs are the best option for mass surveillance. I agree for these kinds of UAVs, but ARGUS [1] blimps are probably super effective and worrisome. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARGUS-IS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARGUS-IS
- harryf 11y ago> Is it a really good way to find potentially dangerous potholes? Probably. It just seems... excessive. It can even make the potholes first by firing off a few missiles
- ATsch 11y ago"since the last update, we have increased our pothole detection by at least 200%"
- deevus 11y agoEdward Snowden talks about this in Citizenfour. ======================================= I also learned at NSA, we could watch drone videos from our desktops. As I saw that, that really hardened me to action. - In real time? - In real time. Yeah, you... it'll stream a lower quality of the video to your desktop. Typically you'd be watching surveillance drones as opposed to actually like you know murder drones where they're going out there and bomb somebody. But you'll have a drone that's just following somebody's house for hours and hours. And you won't know who it is, because you don't have the context for that. But it's just a page, where it's lists and lists of drone feeds in all these different countries, under all these different code names, and you can just click on which one you want to see. ======================================= He doesn't say explicitly that this includes the U.S., but I made that assumption and here it is: proven.
- kobayashi 11y agoThe article says absolutely nothing to support your belief. For your assertion to be credible, there would have had to been many more than <20 flights in ten years.
- cagey_vet 11y agodrones? how about surveillance planes every day i see over gaithersburg seen via SDR
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago“usatoday.com” would like to use your current location.
- tempodox 11y agoThe F.B.I, the N.S.A, the Pentagon, ... We're being governed by criminals.
- cm2187 11y agoWhat I don't understand is that the Pentagon isn't the CIA, it is not prohibited to operate in the US, is it? I mean you have ICBM deployed in the US. What not drones?
- bolivier 11y agoAll I can think is "duh." Why wouldn't the US deploy military drones over her own soil? Who's going to stop them? I doubt any level of wrongdoing within the US Government could shock me anymore.
- Nadya 11y ago>I doubt any level of wrongdoing within the US Government could shock me anymore. Worse is that less and less of the population sees any of the things they do as wrongdoing. After all, they're not doing it for power grabs or control - they're doing it to keep us safe and stop the terrorists and catch the paedophiles! Mass surveillance is one of the first signs of a totalitarian state. History is easier to read about than to learn from. "Not this time." or "That wouldn't happen in {currentYear}" are the defenses. I'm sure those were the same defense several centuries ago. But this time will be different! I'm really scared of what the world will look like in another 2-3 decades.