4 ms·
Actually the rational thing to do would be to start a class action suit forcing the entire fossil fuel industry to pay compensation for the environmental damage
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Actually the rational thing to do would be to start a class action suit forcing the entire fossil fuel industry to pay compensation for the environmental damage it's causing, and to compensate various national economies for the opportunity cost of getting in the way of a move to a clean energy economy.
Which is pretty much what's been happening to Big Tobacco. And it's compensation not prevention.
In tobacco's case, it isn't going to bring any dead people back to life.
I think most people, if asked, would say they'd prefer it if someone they loved hadn't died. Compensation can only go so far to fix that - just as getting the carbon industry to pay compensation won't un-flood any homes that are now underwater.
But this is only necessary because the so-called efficient, so-called market, so-called hypothesis is rhetorical bullshit - precisely because so-called market pricing is calculated in ways that exclude the true long-term costs of the external consequences of short term profit.
A genuinely efficient market would have to factor in the reality-based pricing consequences so that very bad effects became so financially unattractive they were prevented before they could happen.
Without that, you have a wealth extraction playground relying on political privilege to pretend to be something it very much isn't.
- p4wnc6 11y agoWhether a class action is the right approach seems debatable to me. If parties possibly damaged by the externality are entitled to shares of any profit derived from that externality, it acts as an incentive for the company to derive profits in others ways. Rather than a class action that, as you correctly point out, merely gives victims compensation for damage done, it could be better to give potential victims some form of corporate governance. This is all very hypothetical. The chances that an organization couldn't find some political maneuvers to dodge really paying for damages they cause are low. It would be like whack-a-mole. If you incentivize the company to steer away from ocean-raising pollution by letting potential coastal victims have some control, well then they'll just find some other group to extract profits from via unnoticed or unpunished victimization. I'm not sure society wins by engaging in this game of whack-a-mole. The company keeps everyone distracted, the barriers for establishing class action results are high, it's inefficient for us to spend that much time and money on legal routes, and in the meantime, many bad actors simply get away with it and continue to extract profits and consumption opportunities at the expense of others. This is one reason why I prefer to think about direct actions I can do that demonstrably help. Giving to Against Malaria definitely helps someone. Getting all wrapped up in long-term political advocacy for changing the entire framework in which publicly traded companies operate, so as to prevent them from extracting profits via unfair victimization ... that seems like a politics-is-the-mindkiller situation, which will probably do nothing but burn me out and prevent me from doing other things that actually could have helped. Don't get me wrong. It's depressing that it's like this and doesn't bode well for moving towards a more egalitarian society (which I think would be better). But nonetheless it's just the world we live in, litany of Gendlin, yada yada yada.
- Eliezer 11y agoI'm afraid you don't understand what the EMH says. It's not praising markets for being nice or useful or fair or good for the larger economy. EMH just says there are no publicly predictable price movements. "Efficient" is a technical term.