3 ms·
When it comes to the definition for 'derivative', its helpful to look at music videos as an example. They normally don't modify the song, but the video creates
by belorn 11y ago
When it comes to the definition for 'derivative', its helpful to look at music videos as an example. They normally don't modify the song, but the video creates a adaption of the song by applying moving pictures to the music. Such adaptation requires additional copyright permission in most nations, even if someone already have permission to distribute the music unaltered.
When we talk about a kernel module in isolation, its like talking about the moving pictures in a music video without the sound. When we talk about the independently developed OpenZFS Solaris code, we are talking about specific still frames of the video. Each part is required to make the adaption that we call a music video, and each part can be a independent copyrighted work.
Copyright get interpreted by judges and juries who normally take a common sense approach to such problems. Did party X intend to create an adaptation, and if so, did they have permission to do so? I think everyone, including FSC, agree that the Solaris developers did not create an adaptation of the linux kernel. This leaves the people who created the linux module that combined the Solaris code with linux specific adaptation code, and ubuntu that distribute the combination of kernel and module. What decision a jury would decide is to me very uncertain, but one strong argument that sways me towards FSC conclusion is that judges don't like to rule based on technicalities. If something looks like a an adaptation, it is an adaptation.
Going back to the music video example, Youtube currently works by splitting videos into two parts, a video stream and a audio stream. If they argued in court that its the user that link them at run-time, I think they would loose the argument no matter how technically true it is.
- nkurz 11y agoSuch adaptation requires additional copyright permission in most nations, even if someone already have permission to distribute the music unaltered. It's a great comparison on a common sense basis, but could you be more specific? My impression is that in the US there still isn't any definitive "vidding" caselaw. Are you aware of some, or by "most nations" are you referring to the (primarily European) moral rights to the integrity of the work? [1] [1] https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikilegal/Moral_right_of_integrity https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikilegal/Moral_right_of_int...
- belorn 11y agoMoral rights in EU is used to address a different problem, primarily about the association between the author and his work. For example, political advertisement would need to walk careful when using stock-photos or music repositories, since the integrity of the work could be seen as infringed on. It is normally seen as covered by defamation laws in the US, so its not part of US copyright. What I am talking about is Synchronization rights[1]. If a musician has a deal with a publisher, they often want to be paid more if the song is played on a TV commercial then if its played on the radio or distributed on a CD. Most of this I just remember reading about years ago, but I remember that creative commons also address this concept[2]. An other example would be the agreement between NMPA and YouTube in 2011, where YouTube was granted the right to "reproduce, distribute and prepare derivative works (including synchronization rights)". I have not memorized any specific cases where someone challenged this industry practice in court, and digging for one would take a bit more time that I have at the moment. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synchronization_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synchronization_rights [2] https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/legalcode https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/legalcode
- nkurz 11y agoI see now what you are saying, although I'm not sure if the granularity of licensing affects the legality of the redistribution. But that might be because I've been thinking about it solely in the context of noncommercial areas, where "fair use" rather than licensing is the gauge. Once under "fair use", there is no special treatment of synchronization, and there even exists a specific DMCA exclusion for non-commercial video mashups: https://www.eff.org/files/2015/02/09/2014-07_eff_remix_comments.pdf https://www.eff.org/files/2015/02/09/2014-07_eff_remix_comme... Thanks for the followup and the fine example!