3 ms·
I'm just miffed that the company managing my pension somehow feel that they need to my moral guardian. - "How do you want your pension fund invested?" - "Weap
by mrweasel 11y ago
I'm just miffed that the company managing my pension somehow feel that they need to my moral guardian.
- "How do you want your pension fund invested?"
- "Weapons would be good"
- "Sorry, we can't morally justify that"
Well why not? The only that that's happing now is that people who aren't me will be making a profit on those stocks. If running a munitions company is legal, then it shouldn't be morally wrong for my pension to be invested in it.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoLots of things that are morally wrong are legal, and vice versa. There's also an argument (which I think applies to the fossil fuel divestment movement) that having money invested in those industries makes it harder for organisations to speak out against fossil fuels as someone somewhere will be accounting for how that impacts your bottom line negatively. By pre-emptively removing the money, you have more chance of making something illegal (or just heavily, punitively taxed) in the future.
- mrweasel 11y ago>By pre-emptively removing the money, you have more chance of making something illegal Except money isn't actually removed. It's just the money of ordinary people, that is removed. Hedge funds, banks and rich people are still invested in munitions, tobacco, alcohol and fossil fuels. The rest of us for some reason forced to be "better" people, poorer, but better. And don't kind yourself, weapons aren't going anywhere. The US army isn't going to disband because the middle class decides that their pensions won't be invested in Raytheon. It's absolutely bonkers that it's okay for me to want my country to have an army, but morally wrong for me to want to profit from the purchases that army might make.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoI'm not saying "money" is removed, I'm saying "the money", the money under the control of the ordinary people who might play a part in voting for high taxes on coal for example. The more people that negatively affects financally, the less likely it is to happen. If people have 30% of their pension in Marshmallows then the "War on Marshmallows" is going to have a harder time convincing people that Marshmallows are bad.
- golergka 11y agoPraise the open market: you can choose another company to manage your pension.
- mrweasel 11y agoIn Denmark, no. I can choose another company, but they all have the same moral issues.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- probably_wrong 11y agoThe way I see it, your company realizes that they don't exist in a vacuum, and are being socially responsible about their actions. I applaud them. At a slightly more cynical level, maybe they realize that making money from morally wrong investments is bad for business in the long run. I'm also cool with that: That tells me Danish society is keeping "wild" capitalism under control. Of course, that might not be great from a "me above everyone else" mentality, but I think I'm not the only one cool with that.
- VLM 11y agoFor another argument see "green energy" I join a program at my electric company and pay 30% or so more for solar and wind power. I do this. They pool the monthly total KWh I bought at 30% higher rate and contractually buy it from local wind farms. Cool. The problem is I'd like a program where I get 100% of my KWh from the 0.75 cent/KWh "local" nuke plant instead of stinky coal. Where's my "green glow energy" program that drops my electric bill by 50%?
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoThere's no incentive effect there though, they're going to produce that amount anyway, so you buying in is irrelevant. It's even a negative if they have to sell you the electricity they were going to produce and sell anyway, at a lower price.