3 ms·
Sorry, but how is getting the percentage of the Netherlands below sea level wrong an error about rising sea levels? Sea levels are independent from the height o
by Tichy 17y ago
Sorry, but how is getting the percentage of the Netherlands below sea level wrong an error about rising sea levels? Sea levels are independent from the height of the Netherlands for practical purposes (I suppose the Netherlands swallowing less water would actually imply higher sea levels, in case the Netherlands were flooded).
This is not an error that affects climate research.
- anamax 17y ago> This is not an error that affects climate research. If they're wrong about the things that I can check, why should I assume that they're correct about the things that I can't check?
- Tichy 17y agoI am pretty sure if you look hard enough, you can find errors in almost every text. Communication requires a minimum of goodwill on part of the listener. Reminds me of one of my favorite characters, Till Eulenspiegel. His alleged favorite pastime was to misinterpret directions people gave him (because language is ambiguous). Perhaps science should be written in Lojban? Haven't looked into it, but it seems to be designed to be unambiguous.
- zmmmmm 17y agoPerhaps you could sample a large number of their statements and perform a statistical analysis to determine if they wrong with high probability? Oh, yes, that would be a lot of work and we have something called the "scientific process" for doing that anyway. It's much easier to form a snap judgement based on a single, self-selected piece of information.