3 ms·
It largely depends on critical mass. One large institutional investor pulling out isn't going to harm a company because a pure profit seeking firm will pick up
by notahacker 11y ago
It largely depends on critical mass. One large institutional investor pulling out isn't going to harm a company because a pure profit seeking firm will pick up the slack.
But a significant proportion of investors that won't touch a stock is going to have an impact, because even purely rational investors are going to consider the fundamentals of the business affected by the implied lower future liquidity, higher costs of capital and lower ability to retain senior executives with attractive equity offers in future. Even though that impact is unlikely to be large, it's probably large enough for firms keen to avoid being labelled "evil" by activist investors being encouraged to spend a bit more on CSR, tightening up their supply chain and abandoning an unpopular policy or two. It's that secondary effect of encouraging ordinary firms to be more ethically conscious - which GiveWell's article doesn't mention - that's the larger one.
A good analogy is democracy. A few people voting for a fringe candidate doesn't harm the mainstream candidates; awareness there's another party complicating the result might even boost the mainstream candidates' votes. As soon as the fringe party gains some sort of critical mass, however, one of the mainstream candidates is likely to start wooing their supporters by adopting one of their more inoffensive policies in some form.