4 ms·
The one on my phone isn't useless now, because my fingerprint data wasn't stolen in the OPM breach (and nobody else has it either). Even if my fingerprint data
by mikeash 11y ago
The one on my phone isn't useless now, because my fingerprint data wasn't stolen in the OPM breach (and nobody else has it either).
Even if my fingerprint data were out there, that doesn't really help get into my phone if it's casually stolen. The thief won't know who I am, so they won't know which fingerprint to try out of the millions of possibilities. They only get five attempts.
As always, you have to define your threat model. My phone's fingerprint reader protects me against common thieves. It also protects me against the authorities to a pretty large extent. As long as I have the opportunity to turn my phone off beforehand (I always do this when going through customs, for example) then the fingerprint no longer works to unlock my phone. The ease of use that the fingerprint reader provides for most usage allows me to have a much stronger password on the device than I would have otherwise, so I'm pretty sure it's a strong net gain.
It doesn't protect me against a determined adversary who targets me specifically, but then I already knew that. Fingerprint authentication is far from perfect, but it's not meant to be anything else.
- proee 11y agoYou're plastering your fingerprints, aka "keys" over everything you touch. A sophisticated criminal could steal your pint glass and phone at an eatery when you're not looking. There's a chance they could pull your prints off the glass, recreate them on a substrate, and then unlock your phone.
- alextgordon 11y agohttps://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
- mikeash 11y agoSure, but it's about a million times more likely that they won't bother with the fingerprints and will just sell my phone for parts. Nobody is going to be lifting fingerprints off of pint glasses to unlock a phone unless they think there's something really valuable on that phone, and that means "a determined adversary who targets me specifically." Don't keep nuclear bomb plans or thousands of bitcoin on your phone if you're going to protect it with your fingerprint. But mundane e-mails and such? Good enough for me.