5 ms·
Sorry, the quote irritates me to no end (doubly so how people trip over each other to copypaste it). In practice, most opportunities are not a pure savings lik
by SilasX 11y ago
Sorry, the quote irritates me to no end (doubly so how people trip over each other to copypaste it).
In practice, most opportunities are not a pure savings like this where you will end up ahead in every way if only you could borrow the money; usually, you'll end up with more painful feet but more money to spend, as the cheaper shoes aren't completely useless and in need of replacement.
If the quote were as true as claimed, then someone could make a program where helpers pair up with a poor person, loan them 50 dollars, and then let the savings spiral up virtuously -- that loan enabled $100 of savings, which can be reinvested in more savings, when frees up more savings, etc.
But obviously no one's figured out how to make that happen, and the poor can often already get loans of such size and not trigger the upward spiral. So something's missing.
With that said, being poor does tend to be a double whammy where e.g. you live in a places that makes bulk purchases harder ... but it looks nothing like the dynamic in the Vimes copypasta.
- euyyn 11y agoI'm buying a house, because downpayment + misc. costs are going to result in less monthly cost (mortgage + HOA + taxes) than the rent I pay now. The difference is bigger than what I'd obtain by just investing that money somewhere safe. A year ago, with about the same salary but less savings, I wouldn't have been able to meet the 20% downpayment mark, so loan insurance would have make it not profitable. Before that, with even less savings to put as downpayment, just the monthly mortgage payment would have been higher than my rent. I disagree with your premise that the poor can often get loans big enough to make an impact in their lives. And when they do, they tend to be predatory loans.
- SilasX 11y agoThe story is trying to illustrate a specific dynamic: because of being unable to spend a little more in one month [1], you end up having to pay a lot more in later months. You're supporting that by illustrating a situation where being able to come up with a lot of money over a year enables a savings later, which gives a different impression than "look how poor you become from not having $50 one time". I think your example supports my point: being poor has costs, but it doesn't look at all like the dynamic given. >I disagree with your premise that the poor can often get loans big enough to make an impact in their lives. And when they do, they tend to be predatory loans. But if the savings is so sharp, then even a predatory loan could reverse the cycle. In practice, it doesn't. So the theory is incomplete. [1] though inflation since the writing makes the amount larger than it sounds now
- 542458 11y agoI don't think that's quite fair. While the quote oversimplifies it, you too are oversimplifying it. If the boots situation existed your planned boots-loan would never work. Because poor people are high-risk loans, you'd need to put a significant risk factor on that boots loan if you ever hoped to break even (there's a reason credit cards charge 20+% interest). So now the $100 boots are $130 or more. Additionally, nobody not already in heaps of debt would ever take the loan, because people hawking predatory loans and money-for-nothing schemes are a dime a dozen in poor parts of cities (cash4gold! payday loans!) and those who don't lean quickly to ignore them all get screwed. Finally, you're ignoring the psychological aversion to taking on debt, even if it's for the best. Even among fairly well-to-do university students the concept of business leverage seems to come as a bit of a shock, and takes a fair bit of explaining - "But why would you deliberately go into debt?". Imagine trying to explain to somebody below the poverty line that the boots are worth going into debt for!
- SilasX 11y ago>Because poor people are high-risk loans, you'd need to put a significant risk factor on that boots loan if you ever hoped to break even (there's a reason credit cards charge 20+% interest). Well, yeah, but that's the point: it's not that they're $50 away from a perpetually self-reinforcing cycle of rising out of poverty. It's that even if you loaned them the money, and showed them the savings, they still won't take the rudimentary steps (pay back some of the easy savings). (Hence why my disproof involved the example of a charity program.) But at that you'd you'd be using a very different theory of poverty than the Vimes one; it's not that the person couldn't find an extra $50 one time, it's that they are unwilling to plan ahead even when the seed money is given to them. That has a very different moral than the one in the excerpt. >"But why would you deliberately go into debt?". Imagine trying to explain to somebody below the poverty line that the boots are worth going into debt for! So wait, now you're saying the problem is that the poor are too unwilling to borrow?
- Gratsby 11y agoActually, Kiva does exactly that. https://www.kiva.org/ https://www.kiva.org/ > poor can often already get loans of such size and not trigger the upward spiral I don't know about that. Almost all loan-based businesses that target the destitute are predatory. I've seen exactly two that were not. Kiva and my college that gave loans of up to $200 to students for short terms.
- dangerlibrary 11y agoExcept that such institutions do exist, and in many cases they do trigger upwards spirals [1]. The high fixed costs of collection relative to the actual loan amounts drive up the incentive to be a bad actor (on both sides of the transaction) and that makes small amounts of debt much more expensive than large amounts. But the existence of bad actors doesn't invalidate the positive impact access to low-cost loans can create. Also, to your question below about poor people's unwillingness to borrow money: this is absolutely a psychological barrier that can be difficult to overcome, and it's a known problem [2]. It's also not irrational: the increasing instability of wages at the bottom rungs of the economic ladder (last week you got scheduled for 29 hours, this week you got 5 hours) further increases the risk of taking on debt [3][4]. Nothing in the real world is as simple as that quote. People like it because it so clearly captures a very real situation - nobody is going to give you a zero interest loan to stock up on toilet paper, and the poorer you are the less liquid capital you have. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microfinance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microfinance [2] http://www.ihep.org/sites/default/files/uploads/docs/pubs/factsheets/studentaversiontoborrowingfs.pdf http://www.ihep.org/sites/default/files/uploads/docs/pubs/fa... [3] http://www.res.org.uk/details/mediabrief/4410321/Americans-Face-Growing-Wage-Instability.html http://www.res.org.uk/details/mediabrief/4410321/Americans-F... [4] http://www.nbcnews.com/feature/in-plain-sight/shift-change-just-time-scheduling-creates-chaos-workers-n95881 http://www.nbcnews.com/feature/in-plain-sight/shift-change-j...
- SilasX 11y agoBut the Vimes theory was being offered to explain socioeconomic inequality within a society and depends on the "poor" options being more expensive per unit, while the microfinance successes happen mainly via investment of from richer countries into poorer ones, where they have lower prices per unit. (i.e. a dollar buys a lot more stuff in the third world). IOW, to the extent that microfinance has successes, it's in situations that have the opposite dynamic of the Vimes example and do not count as an implication of the theory.
- dangerlibrary 11y agoThere is nothing about the theory of microfinance that relies on the existence of international borders or differences in purchasing power. You have created a straw man. The fact that "impact per dollar" is greater when one is able to exploit purchasing power differences makes it relatively more attractive as a charitable enterprise, so many charity organizations gravitate there, but it is absolutely not a necessary component of a successful microlending structure.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoIt looks exactly like it. I've seen exactly that same dynamic play out with other items of clothing, and even with shoes. And the thing is, when you're poor it's not that you can't afford expensive jeans if you really tried, it's that of necessity if you have that much money to spend on something you have other higher priority needs (things that you've just gone without, or things that you've stretched beyond their useful lifetimes but haven't replaced because you didn't have the money), and not on clothes or shoes. But you see exactly this dynamic play out in housing, transportation, and so many other places. A poor person with bad credit is going to end up being forced into having to take a high interest loan in order to buy even a low quality car. And they're going to have to dump a lot more into maintenance and refurbishment costs than someone who can afford a nicer car. Over several years they may end up having dumped more money into that crappy car and the financing of the loan than it would have cost to buy a much more reliable car if they had the money. I bought my car almost 10 years ago, and had it paid off in less than a year, I've put 100k miles on an incredibly reliable vehicle with almost no spending on maintenance. That saved me a ton of money on financing costs and in maintenance costs. I've seen tons of other people who couldn't do that and ended up buying less reliable vehicles for a lower initial cost but have much more maintenance and end up having to buy yet other cars more frequently. And if you take public transit, you instead spend a ton of money on that without having anything to show for it. Housing is even more extreme. Being able to afford to live near where you work can save a ton of money on travel costs over the long term. And being able to invest in purchasing property puts you way farther ahead than being forced to constantly rent. The point of that little quote is that the difference between rich and poor is very much non-linear, and not merely a factor of the rich having more money. Having more money means being able to spend money in ways that produce solid returns. Buying goods of high quality and high longevity which result in a net savings down the road. And buying things of lasting market value which serve as investments.