5 ms·
I am trying to understand how this reflect reality. If milliseconds gives us HFT wouldn't minutes get rid of the advantage of doing HFT? I.e. the reality is det
by ThomPete 11y ago
I am trying to understand how this reflect reality. If milliseconds gives us HFT wouldn't minutes get rid of the advantage of doing HFT? I.e. the reality is determined by it being milliseconds, seconds, minutes etc. So we can control which reality we want.
As far as I understand HFT, it's not that it's better at predicting the market but rather it's better at taking advantage of micro volatility?
Or am I completely wrong?
- kbenson 11y agoDepending on how queued orders are served at whatever interval the market coalesces at, there will always be some type of high speed trading, even if the frequency isn't as high. In reality (as in any transaction between two individuals), there's no defined interval at which we wait to complete our transactions, we just do them. Adding arbitrary times at which transactions go through creates edge cases, and edge cases can be gamed. Current markets are limited by either an arbitrary interval upon which orders are fulfilled, or as fast as a system can handle them, which is limited by the technology in use. For a very simplistic example of this, if you look at some type of transaction that has extra regulatory requirement/burden that kick in on certain criteria (for example, over a certain price), you should see some interesting behavior when looking at transactions immediately above and below this price level. You'll also likely find interesting solutions to circumvent that rule to capitalize on the reduced competition that allows (to my understanding, this is a semi-accurate high level overview of a part of the derivative mess we found ourselves in a few years back). > As far as I understand HFT, it's not that it's better at predicting the market but rather it's better at taking advantage of micro volatility? My understanding is that you are correct, but in taking advantage of the volatility, they make it a micro level volatility, and both provide a more accurate value of a stock (by reducing the spread), and at a shorter time interval (which together I guess is liquidity). Of course that's all armchair theorizing on my part (in case it came across as overly authoritative or knowledgeable). I'm not a trader, don't work in the industry, and am not an economist. This is just the working model in my mind based on the economics as I see them and my knowledge of the markets, which admittedly is mostly from discussion here...
- ThomPete 11y agoThere will always be some high speed trading but the problem is that once you take it into an territory humans can compete then it's not going to be beneficial for that same High Speed Trading to occur. It's advantage was that it could do it at a speed humans couldn't do. While there is no specific speed at which we make trades we do mostly get our information from the market. If the frequency of updates go down I would guess so would the randomnes of when we make our bets. The frequency of the market affects the randomness of the order. And yes I am really just a Layman although I did do this for Nasdaq :) http://tv.adobe.com/watch/customer-stories-air/nasdaq-market-replay/ http://tv.adobe.com/watch/customer-stories-air/nasdaq-market...
- harryh 11y agoHumans aren't competing against HFTs on speed. That's not an accurate view of the world. Different HFT firms are competing against each other on various bases (one if which is speed) to provide you, a human, the best service.
- ThomPete 11y agoThats not what I am saying either or at least not what I meant to say. What I was trying to say was that humans simply can't do HFT and that the advantage of that is only possible if you have millisecond updates. If you remove that then you remove the advantages of HFT and humans would be able to compete. Whether that is good or bad for the market is another discussion.
- kbenson 11y agoHumans can't compete in the specific thing HFT does, but I'm not sure why humans need to compete there. There's plenty of other areas that humans can compete in (such as analyzing data and market prediction), so it's not like humans are being squeezed out of the market. I don't think making the market quantized (upon reviewing the Nanex story from last week[1], that's apparently the term) makes the problem of people not being able to compete in this small aspect of the market go away, it will just change its nature. Everyone will make trades immediately before and after the point at which it coalesces, otherwise you are leaking information to the market that might be used against you. This requires fast machines, and we're back where be began, with an arms race to see who can submit the most orders in the shortest time right before that point, and who can analyze the orders fastest immediately after (which is specifically the point I was originally making regarding. "sharp edges" and "continuous lines", since the quantized market is essentially a step function). 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11211093 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11211093