4 ms·
EFF Opposes McCaul-Warner Encryption Commission
- krisdol 11y agoDo they try to get this message out to people in congress?
- mordocai 11y agoA large percentage of what they do is lobbying against things like this, so yes. I don't know if they've sent anything out to congress members about this quite yet but if they haven't they will.
- fweespee_ch 11y ago> The makeup of the commission is also an issue. The law enforcement and intelligence community is overrepresented with 6 out of 16 seats. Because 12 of the 16 commission’s members are required to issue subpoenas or approve any conclusions, those 6 members have tremendous influence over the commission’s investigations and the content of any report. Seat stuffing to control the direction of the committee is how you know they bias to control the "commission" in a given direction. The original commission members [both of whom are intelligence/LE biased] + 6 LE officers = 50% control, so it is actually worse than the EFF is saying. > The Warner-McCaul proposal ignores what technical experts, computer scientists, and others have repeatedly told Congress for more than 20 years: weakening encryption standards and mandating backdoors (or key escrow) for government access will make people and their devices less safe. Indeed, the very existence of the Warner-McCaul bill will be used to prolong an unnecessary conversation. Honestly, I think EFF is understating the risk. Its quite possible this Commission won't get vetoed like the EFF believes, particularly given they can try under Obama [who might veto it] and in 2017 under the next president. Its basically veto shopping since it looks like Clinton will win [who won't veto it]. http://www.theverge.com/2015/12/19/10628208/hillary-clinton-back-door-debate http://www.theverge.com/2015/12/19/10628208/hillary-clinton-... > "It doesn't do anybody any good if terrorists can move toward encrypted communication that no law enforcement agency can break into before or after," Clinton said. "There must be some way. I don't know enough about the technology to be able to say what it is, but I have a lot of confidence in our tech experts."
- MawNicker 11y agoUgh. I hate that sentiment at the end. My boss thinks I'm a wizard. I am not a wizard. It's hard to live up to expectations. Especially when it's provably impossible to do what I've been asked and I'm expected to try anyway. How do I know if I haven't tried? Because I'm a wizard and that's not how magic works.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- valine 11y agoI'm always reading articles about how we need more 'programming' classes in high schools. I think what we really need is more education centered around encryption. We can't expect to have intelligent discussions on the importance of internet privacy if the general public can't understand what's at stake.
- drdaeman 11y agoNot really encryption, but information security. And not [not only] the sort of "don't run photo.jpg.exe you got in email"-type stuff, but a course that encourages understanding of how computers and networks work (in simple terms, sure, no need to discuss all the gory details in-depth), how data flows and what does it mean for everyone who can touch that data. Encryption is an important part of this, and understanding the core concepts is critical, but that's not all that counts. For example, the concepts of trust are equally important.
- nitrogen 11y agoWe need more education about the politics, laws, and ethics of engineering in general. Engineers sometimes seem to choose their fields to avoid those issues, but those issues don't avoid them. The only such class I saw offered by the school I attended was taught by a pro-IP paid expert witness, with no obvious coverage of the disadvantages of or alternatives to a traditionally excessive IP regime. Encryption is presented in a similarly one-sided way, and as you say needs more coverage.
- chatmasta 11y agoWe need more computer scientists in congress. I expect we'll see a lot more technically competent politicians in the coming decades. Voters like smart people, and those who were once seen as "nerds" can now garner the respect of everyday Americans. People who "know about computers" are seen as smart. A smooth talking, highly technical, successful startup founder will have a good chance of winning a state-level election. Within 20 years, when all these ignorant fossils in congress finally die, hopefully some smart and technically informed people will replace them.
- 11y ago