4 ms·
raises an interesting philosophical question: If one would commit murder and the victim has already lived 500 years is it then as much a crime as if the victim
by DyslexicAtheist 11y ago
raises an interesting philosophical question: If one would commit murder and the victim has already lived 500 years is it then as much a crime as if the victim were 25 yro?
e.g. Assuming not everyone could afford the technology and you have a 30 yro killer who lacks the funds to rejuvinate committing murder on somebody much older. Would that even be a crime or could it be argued that a 2nd class citizen has only tried to revenge or to set right to what they perceive an unjust society.
Playing god is scary. I think we can only do it if we are really thick enough and full of our selves to believe that certain individuals are better than the rest. (... of course all under the usual disguise of democracy and with a system that ensures the majority of those living under it, that what they do is right and for the greater good).
People suck :-/
- pc86 11y ago> If one would commit murder and the victim has already lived 500 years is it then as much a crime as if the victim were 25 yro? Yes.
- DyslexicAtheist 11y agoyou haven't read or understood my comment. it is neither black nor white.
- cylinder 11y agoWe punish based on intent, not on victim type.
- rogersmith 11y agoNo we don't. Most legal system have some concept of aggravating circumstances if the victim of a particular offense is a certain age, a certain profession, etc
- lloyd-christmas 11y agoWe punish on both victim type and perpetrator type. On the perpetrator side, the punishments themselves are in the context of current lifespan. If the life expectancy jumps to 150, is 36 the new 18? On the victim side: "A Denver Post analysis of five years of state sentencing data found that those convicted of child abuse resulting in death between 2007 and 2011 got prison sentences 25 percent shorter than those who killed adults and were sentenced for the comparable felony charge of second-degree murder." http://www.denverpost.com/failedtodeath/ci_21996958/inequity-exists-length-sentences-deaths-kids-and-adults http://www.denverpost.com/failedtodeath/ci_21996958/inequity...
- Qantourisc 11y agoYou already have that philosophical question now: 1 year old VS 99 year old.
- talideon 11y agoNo need to go so extreme when a more plausible scenario is a 15 year old vs a 65 year old.
- Can_Not 11y agoIt might be more of a crime. Before, you removed the remaining 50 year potential. Now you removed the 500 year potential. One could say the damages increased x10.