3 ms·
ISP cost, backups, patching, hardware upgrades, co-location, DR, insurance, paying for physical and cyber-security, personnel etc. outsourcing allot of those t
by dogma1138 11y ago
ISP cost, backups, patching, hardware upgrades, co-location, DR, insurance, paying for physical and cyber-security, personnel etc.
outsourcing allot of those things saves money it's also a different expense of you buy infrastructure it has value which means depreciation overtime which affects how your accounting is done.
Cloud makes sense for allot of companies not just startups the biggest reason why companies with eatablished infrastructure don't migrate is the initial cost and regulation.
- sharpy 11y ago+1 Not to mention that often it can takes weeks for new hardware order to be approved / delivered / provisioned. Cloud? Just dial it up... Well, if you are at Netflix scale, you probably couldn't just dial it up, and would have to work with the vendor to ensure adequate capacity was available for your use.
- taf2 11y agoAnd keep in mind that adding those new servers even in managed eviromnents can fail and fail in unexpected ways like taking out your whole network. We had this happen with rackspace - hence we moved to Amazon
- hhw 11y agoIf a single point of failure took down your entire network, then your solution wasn't engineered properly. Just because on provider messed up big time doesn't mean every other provider would. The hardwdare design/architecture can also be provided to you for free as part of the sales process, no extra service required. As for hardware failures in general, you can afford to have some complete extra servers on hand doing nothing most of the time with the amount of money you'd save on renting bare metal instead of paying for cloud. Or if engineered properly, you'd be using all the machines at once but be able to afford to lose half of them, and failover automatically. Yes, a cloud (bunch of VMs on a cluster) is going to be more reliable than a single machine, as you get hardware redundancy. But a cluster of machines with hardware redundancy is going to be much more reliable than a bunch of VMs on a cluster, as there's less complexity involved without the cloud stack, and thus fewer points of failure.
- taf2 11y agoIn our case, I mostly agree - we however were led to believe we had network redundancy and when they added new servers and it effectively blacked out access to all servers we realized this was not the case. My realization at the time was simple. It's better to be on a ship with a lot of engineers dedicating their time to a bigger system then hoping an engineer finds the time to check on your one off raft managed solution. Public clouds are an efficiency gain for both the datacenter and the end user. The bottom line to me is more engineers are focused on operating and improving the public cloud than the state of the art managed dedicated racks from 2014.
- Matt3o12_ 11y agoWhy can't you just rent the server from some company? Such a company is only responsible for making sure the hardware works (there are no power outages, the disks work, the network is up and reachable) and you have to make sure your application works and have some failover (because the hardware will eventually fail and they will only replace it, not make up for the loss). You'd still save a lot of money compared to cloud servers, need little admin work (the same compared to compute instances – amazon's EC2 servers), and have a reliable server. Providing the servers doesn't take forever, either. Some bare metal servers are up and running within 120sec, though, you can't just shut them down and stop paying like cloud servers. Companies that offer these services are OVH.com and softlayer, though softlayer always seemed to be a bit expensive. I'm sure you'll be able to find similar companies though. I can see that this makes little sense to startups because the admin work is way more expensive but for bigger companies, this should not be the case (I don't consider Spotify and Netflix a startup anymore).
- Johnny555 11y agoWhy can't you just rent the server from some company? Such a company is only responsible for making sure the hardware works (there are no power outages, the disks work, the network is up and reachable) Isn't that what Amazon does? (even though they are virtual servers)? You'd still save a lot of money compared to cloud servers, Can you post some numbers? A 24 core 48GB Dell server with 3x120GB SSD's costs around $11K, or around $300/month for a 36 month lease. An 8 core 15GB 160GB AWS c3.2xlarge costs around $200 each per month with a 3 year reserved instance. 3 of them will fit in one of the Dells, so it would cost around $600/month, or about $300 more than the raw purchase price for the hardware alone. But also with that price you get network, power, cooling, rack space, maintenance, etc, so it's not clear that buying and running that server is significantly cheaper. Some bare metal servers are up and running within 120sec How long does it take if you want 500 of them? And 2 hours later you want to turn them off. Then 2 hours after that you want to bring them all back online again. you can't just shut them down and stop paying like cloud servers. But that's the big value-add in Cloud servers, it's capacity on demand so you only pay for what you us -- need to spin up 500 servers to run month-end processing? You only need to pay for them for the few hours or days a month when you need them. Further, you can add multi-datacenter or multi-region redundancy at very little additional cost - you don't need to keep those redundant servers running when you're not using them.