You are both right. The softer the science, the worse the effect. I trust physics more than biology, and I trust biology more than sociology. Well, that impl

You are both right. The softer the science, the worse the effect. I trust physics more than biology, and I trust biology more than sociology. Well, that implies I trust sociology... I really don't. Anything softer than physiological psychology is basically in the 'don't trust this until you have verify it, and then still mostly don't trust it'.