4 ms·
Yeah, it's a bit like people taking "Internet Of Things" hype and declaiming that your toaster needs a wireless connection.
by Terr_ 11y ago
Yeah, it's a bit like people taking "Internet Of Things" hype and declaiming that your toaster needs a wireless connection.
- nostrademons 11y agoIf you also sold a robot that could put the toast in the toaster, I'd love a toaster with a wireless connection. I could start breakfast from my smartwatch while I'm still in bed upstairs and only go downstairs when it's ready.
- chipperyman573 11y agoI know you're being sarcastic but I would legitimatly buy something like that if it was under $100
- nostrademons 11y agoI wasn't being sarcastic...I actually would love a toaster that could make breakfast while I was still in bed upstairs. Although one key point that I'm sure IoT entrepreneurs will forget: I want breakfast, not a toaster with an Internet connection. If it doesn't make me breakfast, I'm not interested.
- sharemywin 11y agoI want a "black box" kitchen load the groceries in one side get food on clean plates on the other side. Then, put dishes in a pile that goes in for next time. and it probably needs to be less than $1 per meal since I'm cheap.
- acveilleux 11y agoI'm sure Soylent 5.0 will be pretty close to that.
- livingparadox 11y agothe aforementioned food-maker and Soylent are rather orthogonal technologies. Soylent 2.0 effectively reduces the entire loading step to "order Soylent. Retrieve from porch."
- knicholes 11y agoWould you settle at least for something that correctly measures spices automatically for you so that cooking is easier?
- pjc50 11y agoI have one of those, it's called a spoon. The only extra automation I'd find handy in the kitchen is vegetable chopping, especially for harder things like turnip and squash.
- sharemywin 11y agonot really but about once a week I settle for pizza.
- protomyth 11y agoI really don't want a connected kitchen because I know someone will hack the damn thing to disable the eject function of the toast and I will have to deal with something worse than not being able to turn off an alarm. I can even see the virus's name "Toaster of Flame".
- Retra 11y agoIt'll need to be updated and patched at least once a day, which will result in reliable breakfast delays. I mean, that's how me TV and Playstation work; if I want to use them, I have to wait 30 minutes for an update to happen.
- chriswarbo 11y ago> a robot that could put the toast in the toaster This is almost always the wrong way to solve the problem. Trying to automate a human-friendly interface is far more trouble than it's worth, when you can easily use a machine-friendly interface to begin with. For example, dishwashers aren't robots which stand in front of a sink, squeezing bottles of detergent on to a cloth and rubbing it over a stack of dishes. Instead, they're self-contained beige boxes with a well-defined input/output mechanism (racks to hold the dishes; standard plug for electricity; standard plumbing connections). It's like screen-scraping your own application. Or writing a CLI's main loop with `expect`. Or when sci-fi films show robots typing on computer keyboards. Let's take your example. Unless you're living in a backwards universe I'll assume that you want to put bread in the toaster. There are existing solutions to this, e.g. many hotels have toasters with a conveyor belt; rather than having to line anything up, there's a large catchment area to plonk the bread on to. A harder problem would be separating the slices of the loaf; this can be entirely avoided if the user "loads" a whole loaf at once, like a cartridge. E.g. by inserting paddles between the slices, they won't be exposed enough to go bad, but are easily separated as needed. With everything roughly lined up there's not really anything to control other than turning it on. Plugs with timers are easy to get hold of (I use them for switching on lights in the evening). You could use something smarter like a clapper. Even if you use a "smart plug", there's no need for the toaster itself to be any different.
- nostrademons 11y agoWell, yes. Like I said in a reply to a sibling comment, I really want breakfast. I don't care how it gets made as long as I can decide whether it'll be cereal or waffles or bagels or bacon from upstairs, and it's ready as soon as I get downstairs. In my entrepreneurial dreams (apparently shared by one of the sibling commenters here), I'd actually imagined a fully-automated kitchen. Stick a grocery bag on a shelf (extra points if it integrates with Instacart etc, so that someone else can stick a grocery bag on a shelf), and a robot arm unloads it, reads all the UPC bar codes, and stocks it in a refrigerator. This refrigerator isn't a standard issue one, with a door and shelves, but something with individual bins for items. That way, a robot arm would know exactly what product was in which bin, it could retrieve it, open the package, and measure out whatever quantity is needed for the recipe. Then it goes to the appropriate heating chamber for cooking - it may not even have pots/pans/toasters, just heating elements and containers. Food comes out on clean plates, dirty dishes go in, and the cycle repeats. My interface to it is a smartphone or smartwatch app where I can select a favorite recipe and have it made. I figured this is beyond my hardware capacity to build (unless I exited in some other startup first and had unlimited time to tinker), but if someone else wants to make a go at it...there's the product request. ;-)
- debacle 11y agoThe Internet of Things's main barrier seems to be cost. Do I want a toaster with a wireless connection? Sure. Am I going to pay more than ~$30 for that toaster? No. Do I want that toaster phoning home to Google about my toast-making habits? No way in hell.
- b1530678 11y agoWhat most IoT business fail to understand is that the whole point of IoT is to let devices talk to each other, this scenario will never happen if everyone has their own walled garden with incompatible products. What most people want is something like going home and opening your IoT lock will power on your IoT lightbulbs when it's dark. I don't need a fancy GUI to control my lightbulbs. I can already do that with a regular light switch.