3 ms·
This is a helpful summary! We could also say that blockchains can be useful in principle when people are afraid of retroactive modification of history (for exa
by schoen 11y ago
This is a helpful summary!
We could also say that blockchains can be useful in principle when people are afraid of retroactive modification of history (for example because they get hacked, or because of governmental pressure to falsify their records). This is sort of an instance of this article's mutually-untrusting writers issue, but it's an interesting one because the writers are saying that they don't want to be trusted.
I think this is the case now for software distributors and certificate authorities, among others (I gave a talk related to this at CCC); they are saying "it's bad for us and you if you just believe whatever we say, without at least a way to know if a larger audience has heard it and whether we're denying what we said before".
So we can also say that blockchains (or perhaps another kind of distributed consensus mechanism; clearly Ben Laurie and others are claiming that blockchains are too heavyweight some or all of the time) can be useful when people are afraid that they're going to be made to emit writes that they didn't want to, or to deny writes that they previously emitted.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zimbatm 11y agoFor a CA they could structure their data as a log where each entry (new cert) contains the checksum of the previous entry. That way it's not possible to change the chain without unwinding it. Each person getting a new signed cert now has the new HEAD of the log and unwinding means revoking all these certificates. Now if you put multiple CAs in the game it start to become interesting to use a distributed ledger like the blockchain. If all the signed certs are distributed as part of the ledger it becomes easier to track who issues certs for what domain. Something we cannot do with the current SSL CA system.
- schoen 11y agoThere is already a mechanism in use for letting CAs be transparent about what they've issued. https://www.certificate-transparency.org/ https://www.certificate-transparency.org/ Sorry I didn't mention it explicitly -- I was trying to draw an analogy to show why blockchain-esque mechanisms are relevant here, and I thought readers would already be aware of this system.