4 ms·
The framing of this article very much misunderstands the scientific method. Science is a process. It's a method where you conduct a series of disciplined, rep
by nostrademons 11y ago
The framing of this article very much misunderstands the scientific method.
Science is a process. It's a method where you conduct a series of disciplined, reproducible experiments and use this data to build a model of the truth. Science never gives you the truth directly; instead, you get a series of successively more accurate representations of the truth that you can use to make predictions. Those predictions are not guaranteed to always yield a positive result, but when they come up negative, you have more data with which to refine your theories.
Casting this in black and white terms - "this effect has been debunked" - is doing a disservice to science.
Rather, a negative result in this study should be grounds for further investigation. Why did it come up with different results? Is there something different about how they ran the study? Is there something different about the subjects, something that may hold useful lessons in its own right? Was the original data flawed? Does the effect hold only under certain conditions? All of these would be very useful things to know. The point of science is not to say "This is true and this is not", it's to be able to create increasingly refined models of "This is true under these conditions, and if you apply this model in this situation, you will get these results."
By analogy with physics: the ancient Egyptians (the Ptolemaic kings) believed that the sun revolved around the earth. To make this model work, they had to invent increasingly more complex epicycles in the motions of planets. Copernicus came around and showed that the earth revolved around the sun in a circle. Kepler re-examined this data and said no, planets actually move in ellipsis. Einstein re-examined this data and came up with a tensor calculus that even more accurately predicted the orbits of the outer planets. Now, there is strong evidence that Einstein's theory of general relativity is "wrong" too, but we don't have anything to replace it with.
Was the Ptolemaic calculation wrong? Well, technically not - as my physics professor pointed out, they were just doing a Fourier decomposition of the observed data. And for a kid making a sun-dial on a beach or a hiker who wants to know when the sun will set, the first term of that series is perfectly adequate. But the advantages of the heliocentric and relativistic models are that they can predict the data with increasing accuracy, without adding extraneous magic numbers.
Similarly, when a psychological study can't be replicated, it doesn't necessarily mean the basic idea is useless. Rather, it means that we should look further into the situations where that idea is useless, and refine our models so they gain additional predictive power.
- ksk 11y agoSo then, one could propose any ridiculous hypothesis (e.g. vaccines do not work), and when nobody can reproduce the results, applying your line of argument, it would lead us down a rabbit hole of second guessing and proposing even more complex reasons as to why others are unable to reproduce the results. I think that in the - day-to-day usage of the word / most commonly understood meaning of the word - 'true', it is fair to say that Science is in the business of determining truth from fantasy. Sure, you are permitted under science to investigate anything and everything that pleases you/(your donors :) ). I think that scientific consensus is very closely associated with 'truth'. I totally get the larger point you're making, but even the nature of science itself is a bit of a grey area. I think that some ideas should, and have been laughed out of the room. The so called man-on-the-street does not have time for subtlety or scientific hypotheses which are carefully couched in nuanced terminology. I think that its OK for people to think that science has all the answers, every once in a while :)
- nostrademons 11y agoThe "vaccines cause autism" scare is actually a good example of science working. It was investigated - as it should have been, because if vaccines did cause autism that would be a massive public health crisis - and then they found that the original author falsified the data. The unfortunate part is that that finding hasn't made it into public consciousness the way the original scare did. I think that the belief that science = received truth is behind the rejection of science by a large portion of the population, because it puts it in conflict with other sources of "received truth". People discount evolution as "just a theory" because they're looking for absolute truth; if they were habitually trained to look for evidence and then knew the body of evidence behind evolution, and could compare it with the body of evidence behind gospel, they might understand that "theory" is a lot more rigorously proven than "truth".
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThe idea is clearly not useless, if it is being used to gain additional predictive power, no?
- plainOldText 11y ago