5 ms·
When people claims newer designs have "dramatic safety and proliferation advantages" they make it sound like existing reactor technology is subject to poor safe
by TheSpiceIsLife 11y ago
When people claims newer designs have "dramatic safety and proliferation advantages" they make it sound like existing reactor technology is subject to poor safety record and proliferation problems.
We just isn't true.
The nuclear reactor technology that's been in use for the past 50 years has killed fewer people per kilowatt hour than any of solar, wind, or hydro power [1].
And despite all the proliferation concerns there are only 9 states states with nuclear weapons[2]. You don't magically get nuclear weapons by having domestic nuclear power.
1. http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/#23c9332849d2 http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-de...
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_with_nuclear_weapons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_with_nuclear_we...
- vidarh 11y agoThat's true, but part of this is because of the extreme level of safety and security measures, many of which aren't needed for newer designs. E.g. for a long time the waste was seen as a positive because it could go to weapons manufacture. Yes, you don't magically get weapons that way, but you get raw materials. Security and safety features for these plants must be designed accordingly to prevent accidents and to prevent theft of exceedingly dangerous materials. Especially after the end of the nuclear arms race meant most of this waste wasn't of use any more. Reactors that produces much less dangerous waste can get away without a lot of those issues. Likewise, a lot of the regulatory regime is based on reactors where a mistake or accident can lead to a runaway reaction, but are totally wasted on reactors that are "walk-away safe" because they require an outside, powered, neutron source to keep running for example. Nuclear is amazingly safe, and I like to point that out to people too. But old-style nuclear reactors are that safe thanks to an array of extensive and expensive countermeasures against very real dangers, while at least some of the newer designs, assuming the various claims holds, are safe because the failure scenarios themselves are far more benign. That's the point of these designs. A large proportion of the price of nuclear today is because of these safety features. Remove the need for a good chunk of them, and nuclear becomes far cheaper.
- dredmorbius 11y agoJames Conca is a pro-nuclear advocate. His claims and methodology are rather suspect. The IPCC's SRREN -- a review of carbon-neutral energy alternatives -- notes that nuclear has a good safety record, but is not safer than solar or wind, or hydro in the US and Europe (a couple of absolutely massive dam failures, including China's Banqiao Dam failure in 1975 killing ~175,000 taint the picture elsewhere). Starting at p. 993: http://srren.ipcc-wg3.de/report/IPCC_SRREN_Annex_II.pdf http://srren.ipcc-wg3.de/report/IPCC_SRREN_Annex_II.pdf And p. 745: http://srren.ipcc-wg3.de/report/IPCC_SRREN_Ch10.pdf http://srren.ipcc-wg3.de/report/IPCC_SRREN_Ch10.pdf But, and this is the big but: the most pressing concerns for nuclear power are where it goes wrong from human factors. Including mismanagement, mafia influence (as occurred at Fukushima), unforseen consequences, poor design, terrorism, war, and weapons proliferation. The worst case failure modes for nuclear power are unspeakably bad. For solar and wind, not so much. Global experience to date has been about 400 production reactors, plus construction, supply, waste reprocessing and storage (still not a politically viably solved problem), and decommissioning. Full replacement of present electrical generation only would require some 15,000 plants globally, with ~40 year lifetimes. That's one plant per day being commissioned and decommissioned. Around the world, war and peace, boom-times and recessions. Until doomsday. And nothing will go wrong? And the scene of the 1975 Banqiao disaster isn't some barb-wired glowing hole in the ground, but home to some 7 million plus inhabitants. Dam breaks are bad, but the consequences are fairly short-lived.
- DennisP 11y agoPersonally I'd say the consequences of Banqiao are at least as long-lived as the previously-expected remaining lifespans of its 175,000 victims.
- dredmorbius 11y agoLook up Banqiao at Wikipedia. The failure was only peripherally a consequence of the dam and far more one of poor system planning, poor engineering, poor management, poor communication, a thousand-year storm (1,000+ mm rain in 24 hours), resulting comms failures, and the inevitable dam failure. A relatively small proportion of the deaths were directly due to flooding. Most occurred from disease and starvation -- far more infrastructure and response failures than the catastrophe itself. Even given massive flooding, access to a solidly-constructed building 2-3 stories tall would suffice to provide protection from immediate risks, as would comms, evacuation and response plans, emergency and relief supplies, etc. China is a country which in the past century has seen tens of millions of deaths from starvation alone, most recently about 20 years before Banqiao. On the scale of Chinese tragedies, of which there've been many, this was relatively modest. And, as noted, the region is more than fully recovered. Contrast Chernobyl and Fukushima. 30 years after Chernobyl (the anniversary will be this April), primary containment still isn't achieved. Radiation risk was presented across an entire continen, including the 450 million inhabitants of Europe. Eating of wild foods in Germany is still restricted (particularly mushrooms and boar). Fukushima likewise still hasn't stabilised five years on, and remains uncontained. Nuclear accidents have very long risk tails. And all of the management, engineering, communications, and response failures of Banqiao apply equally to nuclear power. The industry is quite fond of downplaying risks. Has done so since the first experiments. Wanting a thing doesn't make it so.
- DennisP 11y agoI do agree with all that. Modern conventional reactor have achieved admirable safety. But they've done that with a lot of complicated and expensive safety mechanisms. With a reactor that's inherently safer due to the physics of fuel and coolant, you don't need as much of that, and have the potential to achieve lower costs. I also agree that proliferation is an overblown concern, but the international community does have some level of discomfort with nuclear power in third-world countries. If we could provide them with, say, a Transatomic reactor that runs on very low-enriched uranium and produces very little plutonium, that would go a long way towards alleviating that concern.
- lrearden 11y agoExactly! Most all of these concepts do not have proliferation risks. And many can destroy weapons material. However, these groups have to be careful about what they can do with the fuel cycle. Transatomic gets a lot of press, but their technology has glaring holes. They cannot burn waste well at all. You have to have fast neutrons and only fast neutrons to do that. Their claim of a dual spectrum is a brush over of this issue. The thermal neutrons account for 95% of reactions and thermal neutrons have a tendency to transmute fissile actinides into higher and higher transuranic actinides until you have so much stuff like Pu-240 and Cm-244 that you cannot continue the chain reaction. TAP only gets an extra 30 MWD/kg out of spent fuel at most before their salt saturates with too many non-fissile actinides so the reaction cannot continue. Compare this to a fast reactor that can get 200-700 MWD/kg. There are salt designs that can do this, but not this one.