6 ms·
> stolen scan Erm, even if it's scanned, it's a scan of an object that is pretty much in public domain. Not sure the use of the word "stolen" is appropriate he
by ekianjo 11y ago
> stolen scan
Erm, even if it's scanned, it's a scan of an object that is pretty much in public domain. Not sure the use of the word "stolen" is appropriate here (as usual) - it's more like they got access to it.
- Mithaldu 11y agoCopyright would apply to the scan, same as any photo you make of something is copyrighted to you.
- Alex3917 11y ago> Copyright would apply to the scan Not if it's a slavish reproduction.
- yig 11y agoIn many jurisdictions, faithful reproductions are not copyrightable: https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Reuse_of_PD-Art_photographs https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Reuse_of_PD-Art...
- consp 11y agoTrue, but it is if you have to actually create it yourself and if it costs considerable effort and is done with a new technique. As some people have already stated: The detail is much too high to be created as a self-created, new method, production (e.g. scanned with a kinect2 by walking around). And I also wonder what the effect of tempered glass is on the scan (as most glass will block near uv and ir, since they might want to keep the original in good condition. -- update to clarify
- dredmorbius 11y agoWorkfactor isn't a criterion of copyright (under US law). Authorship is. Composing, framing, and timing a shutter release is considered "authorship" so far as photography is concerned. Not sure a scan meant to be fully faithful to an original would be.
- ygra 11y agoIn Germany they are, as the country-specific notes on that linked page tell you.
- huskyr 11y agoNot necessarily. Reproductions of public domain works that have no 'creative input', such as photographs of 2d-works like paintings are usually not eligible for copyright protection. You could argue the same is true for a perfect 3d-scan of a PD work: there is no creative process.
- baldfat 11y agoI love that people even have the idea that these items of antiquity which can belong to someone and they can make a copyright. The obvious answer (to me) is that they are public domain and are humanities public record. Now the item may be owned but cannot copyright the image. This should be the answer.
- neves 11y agoThis item is from the cultural heritage of Egypt. It belongs to the country. German has stolen it.
- baldfat 11y agoBut should Egypt own the copyright image is my question? My answer is no.
- kpil 11y agoThe dude that made it? The copyright expired a while ago then...
- baldfat 11y agoWell then they say that the person making the image with a camera or a scanner has copyright to their "Art Work." If the picture or scan is 100% a representative of the object it shouldn't have a artistic license to keep that away.
- mesozoic 11y agoLuckily the copyright on a ancient work of art would have expired long ago.
- bpicolo 11y agoHow does copyright apply to a 3300 year old statue?
- return0 11y agoIndeed, but people should be able to freely make 3d scans and the museum should have no right to prevent that.
- logfromblammo 11y agoThe scanning process may interfere with the ability of other members of the public to enjoy the work in the usual way. The scanning process may damage the object in some small way, which could accumulate over the course of multiple scans. The queue for making volume scans may be packed with amateurs, who will make low-quality scans, with limited distribution. These might prevent the timely creation of a high-quality scan. So it is really in the interest of the public to allow the most competent scanner to jump the queue, make the best possible scan with available technology, and distribute that to everyone who wanted a scan in lieu of allowing them to make their own. If a work of art is removed from exhibit once every decade or so for a new scan that is better than the last scan, and that is distributed libre to any visitor that wants a copy, there is no argument to be made for anyone to make another scan, unless it can add information that is not already in the existing files. For instance, if the usual scan relies on reflected visible light, a magnetic scan or transmitted light could reveal other information, such as perhaps a previous image that was painted over.
- woah 11y agoDo you also feel this way about photos?
- logfromblammo 11y agoWhich do you mean? Photos of a museum piece or photos as the exhibited work? For the latter, if the photos were taken on film, reproduction prints could be made in the same fashion as the exhibited print, and any scanning should take place using the negatives. On-plate photography is more appropriately digitized using a scanning machine, rather than with a handheld photographic camera. As for taking pictures of a museum piece, as long as you are no more disruptive than someone using their eyeballs, I have no problem with taking photographs, even if the displayed work is still under copyright. A blanket ban on photography puts an unfair burden on the photographer to prove fair use a priori. If there is a problem with copyright, the work in question can always be blurred or blacked out with digital editing, leaving the remainder of the photo intact. But I don't believe any public museum can ethically prevent visitors from using recording devices of any kind unless they provide libre digital copies of the protected work that are objectively better than anything that could be produced by an amateur in situ. So by all means, charge 8000 euro for a volume-printed reproduction of the bust. But if you want to prevent people from "scanning" the original, you had best make the high-resolution scan the museum already possesses available for download first.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThat question is part of the interesting discussion. If you scan a statue and then print that scan, you've clearly made a copy of something. So the scan is, by some definitions, also "the thing". But you created the scan and had to clean it up and fix weird bugs where a pixel was out of place etc, so the scan is also its own thing. So one argument goes that making the scan is a creative process and it gets its own copyright, and using that scan to produce a copy of a piece of art goes to a different copyright. But is that printed copy a derivative work? or a copy? Was the scan "new art"? or was it "technical recreation?" There are a lot of interesting angles. I heard a discussion on NPR about paintings that had been severely damaged due to natural disasters and museums hired artists who were familiar with the style, and with materials similar to the original artists, work to restore the painting from pictures of its previous state. Of course the restoration artists can't exactly reproduce the painting and they bring their own talent and creativity to the process. So are they now part owner of the copyright? Is it a partnership work? One artist dead, the other alive? Clearly if it was a work for hire with copyright assignment that is moot for the artist but does the museum now have some claim of copyright? Some of the more interesting rabbit holes you can get lost in when you take a very technical approach to copyright.
- noonespecial 11y ago"Intellectual property" is not a water-tight abstraction. It definitely leaks around the edges. The next decade or so is all about the edges.
- pnathan 11y agoSuppose you scanned the Ship of Thesus at the port where it docked, and then printed each board out. Would the recombination of the boards make the Ship again, or wouldn't it? I always find it fascinating amazing what 2000-year old questions still have bearing on technology recently created.
- ktRolster 11y ago>But is that printed copy a derivative work? It's clearly a derivative work. If printing a copy is transformative (and my opinion is no, it's not), then it is also gets its own copyright. So the owner of the original work doesn't get the copyright of the new work, but can still sue for infringement. There was a case on this topic recently.
- madaxe_again 11y agoPlus, if one wants to talk about stolen things, Borchardt's negotiation to acquire the bust is... Interesting.