3 ms·
Still, I liked his can opener analogy. Yes, robot can openers might help the disabled, but I bet that was not why they were invented. Let's call robot can opene
by Tichy 17y ago
Still, I liked his can opener analogy. Yes, robot can openers might help the disabled, but I bet that was not why they were invented. Let's call robot can openers for the disabled a completely different product than robot can openers for non-disabled. Then his point still stands.
But: nothing against tinkering, a ka creating robot can openers just because we can.
- petercooper 17y agoAutomatic transmissions weren't invented for the disabled either. Would his point stand for those? After all, driving stick is only a little extra effort.
- Tichy 17y agoI am not a driver, but I assume automatic transmission make driving easier. The can openers in his example made opening cans more difficult. I don't think he is arguing against technological progress in general. Anyway, I see it more as a poetical piece. People will vote with their feet/money anyway.
- petercooper 17y agoThe can openers in his example made opening cans more difficult. Yeah, but his point was nonsensical (or at least hyperbole). He said: and usually the can ends up half-open, half-bent up to the point where it's un-openable short of dynamite. Automated can openers usually spoil cans? If that were true, people wouldn't use them because most of their food would go to waste.
- Tichy 17y agoStill, why do people buy automated can openers, or electric pepper mills? Unless they are disabled, it just seems to be such a waste. His experience was that the can openers never worked, but his parents kept trying and buying new models. Maybe by now they work. Still I don't see why anyone would want to have one. Call me a treehugger, but why waste energy and produce toxic waste for something you could easily do manually.
- elblanco 17y agoYou say this like a man who's never been stuck in stop and go traffic for 3 hours a day for 5 years.