5 ms·
This should be a HN FAQ because every time the topic comes up, someone makes your invalid argument. Well, it's not really an argument but more of the sympathy
by melling 11y ago
This should be a HN FAQ because every time the topic comes up, someone makes your invalid argument. Well, it's not really an argument but more of the sympathy card.
It cost billions to develop a drug and pennies to make it. Can you explain the business model where companies don't go out of business and research dries up? India is creating drug resistant bacteria because antibiotics are so overused.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/04/world/asia/superbugs-kill-indias-babies-and-pose-an-overseas-threat.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/04/world/asia/superbugs-kill-...
Who's going to pay for the research needed to prevent a pandemic?
I'm going to write a blog so this question doesn't need to be answered every couple of months.
How about India with a million people turning 18 every month (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11232383 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11232383), develop a drug industry to create better and cheaper new drugs, while creating great jobs for people who need them?
Of course, if you simply give away everyone's work, no company is going to stay in business.
- dineshp2 11y agoMy point was that innovation and financial reward need to be decoupled to ensure valuable knowledge is not locked behind IP. > Of course, if you simply give away everyone's work, no company is going to stay in business. To think about a future without ridiculous restrictions on access to knowledge(which IP law promotes implicitly), it is important to stop accepting the status quo in which innovation and financial reward are directly linked. You seem to accept the reality that innovation has to be linked to financial reward by gaining exclusive rights over the invention using IP laws,which,respectfully,is preposterous.
- melling 11y agoCan you provide some concrete examples of the business model, and how it works? Perhaps some new agile startups could disrupt big pharma. You can't realistically expect people to accept that you have a better plan without offering real evidence that it works.
- dineshp2 11y agoI don't claim to have a magical solution for the problems but what I can do is get people talking about the current system and potential solutions. Isn't that the first step towards solving any problem? I plan to share some of my thoughts and potential solutions in a blog post, and I will be sure to share it here.
- iofj 11y ago> Who's going to pay for the research needed to prevent a pandemic? Actually given that this is a real threat, someone will. Even if only to save themselves. And because they'd have extreme problems if they saved only themselves, rather than the entire civilization supporting them, they'll make it available to others too. Yes this is hardball negotiating 101 : if doing something solves a strategic risk for someone, don't pay them a dime to do it. You may even consider making it more expensive for them to do, if that provides you with an advantage.
- puissance 11y agoMight be unrelated to the topic but I don't understand how you came up with the summation "India is creating a drug resistant bacteria because antibiotics are overused" from that nytimes article. The same article also mentions that the overuse of antibiotics in US factory farms has also lead to outbreaks of drug-resistant diseases in recent years. Yes it mentions that there's been a clampdown from 2000 to 2010, but I am skeptical of accepting this fact without numbers. Can I go ahead and say that US will be responsible for creating drug resistant bacteria? You may not know this, but one of the major outbreaks of drug-resistant superbugs is because of Indian drug manufacturers exploiting lax environmental laws to dump anti-bacterial refuse into village waterways. A large number of these manufacturers are contracted by US big pharma because it is much cheaper to produce (even patent-protected) drugs in India. If you're interested, here's the bad medicine report on it https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.sumofus.org/images/BAD_MEDICINE_final_report.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.sumofus.org/images/BAD_MEDICINE_.... My point is no one country or entity can be blamed for the rise of superbugs. The problem is systemic and it needs us to step out of our reductionist paradigm to solve it.