7 ms·
The author still wouldn't approve of direct democracy either: they think all democracy is non-consent, and do not recognise societal majority as a form of conse
by nailer 11y ago
The author still wouldn't approve of direct democracy either: they think all democracy is non-consent, and do not recognise societal majority as a form of consent. The author is arguing for anarchism, which generally doesn't scale beyond one person. As soon as you have multiple people and they disagree, you need some mechanism to fix the tie. This is obvious to most adult humans, which is why I'm surprised the article made it to WP.
As the other poster notes with the example of Switzerland, the solution to governments straying too far from the will of the people is more democracy, rathe than abandoning the will of the people.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoAnarchism can work at a larger scale, look at the success of revolutionary Spain. Anarchism can take many forms, the people can decide how they want their government to look. Anarchism merely rejects any form of authoritarianism. Well I don't agree with the author because he appears to be a right-wing, or American libertarian, who overlook the inherent authoritarianism and tyranny of corporations.
- mike_hearn 11y agoWhat are you referring to? Spain has never been a long term example of anarchy. It has been a dictatorship many times though.
- Synaesthesia 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Catalonia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Catalonia It was quickly crushed by all the other global powers together, the Soviet Union, the West, and the Franco Nationalists with the Nazi's. But while it existed, it was very successful. Read Orwell's "Homage to Catalonia" to get an impression of it.
- mike_hearn 11y agoRevolutionary Catalonia wasn't anarchist - your own source says "Although the Catalonian Generalitat was nominally in power, the trade unions were de facto in command of most of the economy and military forces." Socialist trade unions and anarchists are pretty much at opposite ends of the spectrum (assuming the anarchists are actually anarchists .... my experience of such people is that they often claim to be, but when the rubber hits the road they turn out to be communists too)
- icebraining 11y agoAnarcho-syndicalism is a well known concept. If you are of the opinion that it isn't actually anarchist, you should just say so, otherwise people will just talk past each other.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoCan't reply to your post down the thread for some reason, but your characterisation of trade unions as being anti-anarchist is a strawman. Go read about Anarchist Spain, it was a huge success, literacy shot up, productivity went up massively, it enjoyed broad popular support, it wasn't perfect but it functioned well, well enough to be considered a threat by the existing powers. Another example of a successful anarchist society is the Rojava government of the Kurds in Syria, as mentioned in the thread.
- kijin 11y agoThe author seems to be a libertarian, not an anarchist. If he has any sympathy for anarchism, it seems to be for the philosophical kind [1] rather than the practical kind that you say is impossible. Or perhaps his position might be closest to the "natural duty" argument for political obligation [2], which isn't all that far off from philosophical anarchism anyway. The central premise of both philosophical anarchism and the natural duty argument is that governments have no legitimacy whatsoever by default, and only gain legitimacy to the extent that they help bring about beneficial consequences. The two theories differ in block size. Philosophical anarchism only acknowledges the value of individual pieces of law (if at all) that they think are beneficial, whereas the natural duty folks are more willing to give their blessing to entire systems of government in a broad brush. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_anarchism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_anarchism [2] http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/political-obligation/#NatDut http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/political-obligation/#NatD...
- circlefavshape 11y ago> The author is arguing for anarchism, which generally doesn't scale beyond one person Anarchism has been the default way of running the show for most of our species's existence. Civilization is only 10 thousand years old. Seems to me like it's population density rather than numbers that anarchism has trouble with
- oldmanjay 11y agoThere's also the fact that the historical anarchic societies didn't achieve much, whereas modern civilization...well, you're on the Internet. The point I'm making should be clear.
- nailer 11y ago> Civilization is only 10 thousand years old. Tribal societies generally had leaders, decided by ability, combat, or other means.
- mhaymo 11y agoYou are clearly misrepresenting the author. The second part of the article starts with a concession that democracy is beneficial despite the lack of consent. He is arguing that the non-consensual nature of government suggests limited local government is preferable to needlessly invasive global government. Here's a relevant snippet: > Nonconsensual government must be subject to a substantial burden of proof when it exercises coercive authority, and it may often fail to meet it. The nonconsensual nature of most government policies also strengthens the case for devolving power to regional and local authorities in order to increase the number of issues on which citizens can “vote with their feet” and thereby exercise at least some degree of meaningful consent.