3 ms·
Let's certainly not let the risks or difficulties of operating nuclear reactors or disposing of their waste get in the way of nuclear startups. Fortunately, tho
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Let's certainly not let the risks or difficulties of operating nuclear reactors or disposing of their waste get in the way of nuclear startups. Fortunately, those from the West Coast only look at the upside of these things per DeWitte. An attitude that existed during the Manhattan Project and some reactors with serious issues. I can't wait to see what comes of this.
Even the author of Learned Optimism that brought us Cognitive Therapy pointed out that pessimism made sense when we're talking risk management. The context here is nuclear materials. I have a hard time being optimistic given what past 60+ years have shown us about that.
- jfoutz 11y agoNuclear was the first kind of energy production without externalized costs (mostly). Solar seems pretty good, but i think the manufacturing is pretty toxic. I guess the same could be said of the concrete in nuclear reactors. having a plan for dealing with waste and paying for that plan from the start is pretty cool. Even if the plan sucks, it's way way better than our plans for coal and oil. Which, as far as i can tell, is to just not worry about it. edit I guess there's no good plan, but it's not like the reactor operators wake up one Tuesday and wonder where their waste went. Unlike me when i drive. Carbon is much more dump it in the air and hope for the best. Nuclear waste is, as far as i know, logged, tracked, audited and generally completely accounted for.
- legulere 11y agoNuclear waste management is a partly externalized cost (nuclear waste will outlive the companies that produced them). Sometimes decomissioning is externalized (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/THTR-300#Decommissioning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/THTR-300#Decommissioning). The effects of Uranium mining are externalized (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wismut_(mining_company)#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wismut_(mining_company)#Histor...). The effects of Chernobyl and Fukushima were externalized. E.g. many boars are still too radioactive for human consumption in Germany.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoAre these things you're comparing nuclear to guaranteed to be a problem for thousands of years? Or are they just chemicals that we might recombine or destroy in various ways? I'm pretty sure they're the latter. I'm not aware of anything that turns radioactive waste into non-radioactive waste. Far as toxic waste, we could always build more of these maybe: http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/energy/plasma-converter.htm http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/energy/plasma... Even that article mentions a specific type of waste as an exception that can cause fire or explosions in the equipment. Even mighty plasma has trouble with it. What hope is there for other methods? ;)
- pdkl95 11y ago> I'm not aware of anything that turns radioactive waste into non-radioactive waste. You use a breeder reactor. Some of the designs for thorium breeders, for example, can be used to process existing waste from other reactors. > guaranteed to be a problem for thousands of years? Note that it gets safer over time as it decays, and in general the radiation danger of an isotope goes down the longer the half-life. Once you get into the particularly long lived isotopes, the radiation danger becomes very small. Also, the amount of waste is trivial; nuclear power only makes a millionth the waste as traditional power, because of the vast difference in usable energy density. Even if you consider the waste that stays around for "thousands of years", that's a short time compared to some types of chemical waste that doesn't decay. How many Superfund sites already exist?[1] There are quite a few in Silicon Valley[2]. [1] http://toxmap-classic.nlm.nih.gov/toxmap/combo/mapControls.do http://toxmap-classic.nlm.nih.gov/toxmap/combo/mapControls.d... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Superfund_sites_in_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Superfund_sites_in_Cal...
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"Even if you consider the waste that stays around for "thousands of years", that's a short time compared to some types of chemical waste that doesn't decay." I did mention a plasma converter and the possibility of chemical options coming up down the line. Not many possibilities like that for nuclear.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 11y agoEven if we were to intentionally just scatter all the nuclear waste along road sides in urban areas, nuclear would likely still remain one of the safest power sources. Disposing the waste is largely a political problem. And that is with old designs producing nasty waste. There are newer designs that would be able to reuse some of that waste as fuels, and there are many newer designs that produces far less dangerous waste to begin with.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"Even if we were to intentionally just scatter all the nuclear waste along road sides in urban areas, nuclear would likely still remain one of the safest power sources." It would be if you ignore the effects of radiation on biological and electronic systems. If you don't, the idea is as ridiculous as you may have intended. "Disposing the waste is largely a political problem." It's actually a problem of making a material non-radioactive or storing arbitrary amounts of it safely for longer than we've existed as a civilization. Neither is a political problem: one is impossible so far per science; other faces risks from logistics, environment, personnel, and politicians. I'd expect us to be able to build out CO2 capture systems at local power plants before we could successfully counter all the above for thousands of years straight given global issues. So, no, it is one of the least safe power sources if one considers the risks of operation or waste. Japan had a recent reminder of that.