3 ms·
You're right in that the system is vulnerable, but this doesn't mean that it's not "secure" in practical terms. One could argue that the phone is secure becaus
by predakanga 11y ago
You're right in that the system is vulnerable, but this doesn't mean that it's not "secure" in practical terms.
One could argue that the phone is secure because even Apple has no way of recovering your passcode, nor do they have a master key that might give access to your data. That's fairly secure.
On the other hand, the system is insecure because it can have updates applied (which is what the FBI wants Apple to do) without requiring user consent, only physical access.
Imagine that updates required a user to put in their passcode, or otherwise wiped all the encrypted data; it would be more secure, but is that enough? Theoretically, there are still ways of getting at the data - someone might find a bug in the software, or they might physically crack open the CPU to get at a piece of needed data.
Security is always a balance - we want to trust Apple as little as possible, but I know of no way to create an invulnerable system.
- greggman 11y agoI'm probably just not remembering it correctly but I know of no way to apply updates to a locked iPhone. Even when unlocked if you plug it into a new computer the phone will ask if you trust the new computer. Is there some method of updating the phone when it's locked I'm unaware of?
- nicky0 11y agoI think it's some kind of device recovery mode designed to recover from "bricked device" situations. It's not the same method that you use when updating via iTunes.
- predakanga 11y agoAye, it's called Device Firmware Upgrade (or DFU) mode, and it's specifically mentioned in the FBI's request: > "The SIF will be loaded via Device Firmware Upgrade (“DFU”) mode, recovery mode, or other applicable mode available to the FBI."