7 ms·
"But the soldier pays the biggest part of the bill" I'm not sure how it was in Butler's time, but I've read that the overwhelming majority of casualties in mod
by pmoriarty 11y ago
"But the soldier pays the biggest part of the bill"
I'm not sure how it was in Butler's time, but I've read that the overwhelming majority of casualties in modern warfare are civilians. It would seem to me that they are the ones who pay "the biggest part of the bill".
Not that I would deny that the people doing the mass murder can themselves become the victims of war. But I'd personally have more sympathy for civilians who are not trying to murder others but are themselves murdered.
- sandworm101 11y ago>> born July 30, 1881 So yes, he didn't witness a truly modern war. 19th century conflicts were brutal, but weren't exactly the city-destroying conflict WWII was, nor the guerrilla wars of modern times.
- HillRat 11y agoThough you could argue that the Philippines war had its similarities to modern three-block-war conflicts; see Mark Twain on the Moro Crater Massacre (http://drnissani.net/MNISSANI/cr/moro.htm http://drnissani.net/MNISSANI/cr/moro.htm).
- eru 11y agoDon't forget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiping_Rebellion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiping_Rebellion : "The [Taiping Rebellion] [...] ranks as one of the bloodiest wars in human history, the bloodiest civil war, and the largest conflict of the nineteenth century with estimates of war dead ranging from 20 to 70 million dead, as well as millions more displaced."
- fleshweasel 11y agoHe participated in WW1, which by any reasonable standard was a truly modern war.
- danielvf 11y agoBut his book was not about WWI, rather about the smaller banana conflicts.
- rangibaby 11y agoWWI still didn't have total war or deliberate destruction of entire cities using aircraft. The bombing of Guernica in 1937 was considered shocking at the time.
- cubano 11y agoYou are wrong about that. WWI eventually defined total war, and no doubt its legacy was the primary reason France just surrendered to the Germans in 1941. The entire population had simply had enough. Hell, Sherman was fighting total war in 1864.
- rat87 11y ago> Some 9 to 10 million combatants on both sides are estimated to have died during World War I, along with an estimated 6.6 million civilians.[citation needed] The civilian casualty ratio in World War I is therefore approximately 2:3 or 40%. Most of the civilian fatalities were due to famine or Spanish flu rather than military action. The relatively low ratio of civilian casualties in this war is due to the fact that the front lines on the main battlefront, the Western Front, were static for most of the war, so that civilians were able to avoid the combat zones. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#World_War_I https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#World_... > According to most sources, World War II was the most lethal war in world history, with some 70 million killed in six years. The civilian to combatant fatality ratio in World War II lies somewhere between 3:2 and 2:1, or from 60% to 67%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#World_...
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoI found out recently that "Spanish Flu" is so called because all the countries fighting in the war censored any mention of it happening in their camps, where it almost certainly originated. From wikipedia: "To maintain morale, wartime censors minimized early reports of illness and mortality in Germany, Britain, France, and the United States;[9][10] but papers were free to report the epidemic's effects in neutral Spain (such as the grave illness of King Alfonso XIII),[11] creating a false impression of Spain as especially hard hit[12]—thus the pandemic's nickname Spanish flu." and Investigative work by a British team led by virologist John Oxford[15] of St Bartholomew's Hospital and the Royal London Hospital identified a major troop staging and hospital camp in Étaples, France, as almost certainly being the center of the 1918 flu pandemic. A significant precursor virus, harbored in birds, mutated to pigs that were kept near the front.[16]
- rodgerd 11y agoThe murder, torture, and rape of civilians all out of proportion of any millitary casualties is hardly a modern phenomenon. The US brutalisation of the Phillipines. The Hundred Years' War. The Thirty Years War. Three off the top of my head, and it's easier to find more examples than to find counter-examples.
- Semiapies 11y agoThe military always thinks they have the worst of war. Remember all those stories a couple of years back about drone operators being psychologically traumatized by their job? (In between calling children they'd killed "fun-sized terrorists", of course.)
- deelowe 11y agoCan't both sides have it bad? I have family members who were absolutely traumatized by the vietnam war. The whole concept is absolutely terrible.
- EdHominem 11y agoNot really. The worst a soldier faced was prison for not participating and if they left the country soon enough - no punishment at all. Anyone unwilling to go to some effort to avoid prosecuting an unjust war can't really be said to be a victim like the people they shoot... If we give them a pass we remove all moral requirement to make sure you're fighting for a just cause.
- codyb 11y agoI'm not really sure if, during a national wartime it's always just so easy for millions of potential soldiers to just pack up and move across the border at once. Otherwise, your option is only for those who are economically, and mentally prepared for such an undertaking. Economically of course including things like important connections. And your other option which I think is jail for draft dodgers isn't exactly fulsome and charming. So the soldier either loses his way of life through exodus, forced incaceration, or being sent to fight.
- Semiapies 11y agoAnd yet all of that falls short of what civilians in war zones suffer. Hence, the idea that the military gets the worst part of war is ridiculous.
- prawn 11y agoAnd also don't get paid for their involvement.
- desdiv 11y agohttp://i.imgur.com/DS57Lrk.png http://i.imgur.com/DS57Lrk.png