3 ms·
If you actually study the history, the single most common reason that people go to war is due to a lack of resources of some sort. Food or something critical to
by Mz 11y ago
If you actually study the history, the single most common reason that people go to war is due to a lack of resources of some sort. Food or something critical to the economy or whatever. (Edit: There are a MILLION explanations, but scarcity of resources or insufficient resources of some sort is almost always the actual root cause.)
So, again: "There aren't enough resources" is essentially what people mean when they say "There are too many people." Sending people to war -- win, lose or draw -- tends to get the number of people down and may have long term impact on keeping the number down by removing the potential for those who died young on the field of battle to reproduce at all.
You can claim all you like that "BUT, THAT isn't THE REASON we go to war" and, you know, it just makes me think you have no understanding of history. It doesn't convince me you are right.
- mc32 11y agoIf by men you mean people, ok. But he said too many "men". But its still backwards, its like when someone says, oh my food is too cold and you say, no, it's not too cold at all, it's simply not hot enough. Often times wars were fought for stability. If you were stronger the weaker adversaries would be less likely to wage war against you. So your going to war was more to counteract someone else's lack of resources who might fight for them rather than your need for resources... Anyhow it like saying we went to war because we wanted to live longer.... Ok. Yes, but that's not how we typically present the issue.
- Mz 11y agoSo your going to war was more to counteract someone else's lack of resources who might fight for them rather than your need for resources... This is causing me a blue screen of death moment. You are disagreeing with me by saying "But the war could start because of someone else's lack of resources..." and I cannot fathom how that is an argument against the idea that a lack of resources is almost always the root cause. So, I think I shall step away from this discussion now. Thank you.
- mc32 11y agoOne is cause the other effect.
- Alex3917 11y agoIf countries really started wars to reduce their populations, they'd send women to war instead of men.
- dalke 11y agoBroadly speaking, you are right. "I want your land" can be interpreted as meaning "I don't have enough land" and need Lebensraum. The Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire could be interpreted as Spain not having enough gold, land, and people. The US invasions of Panama and Grenada could be interpreted as due to a lack of pro-Americans in power in nearby countries. The Norse fights with the Dorset and Thule "skraelings" could be interpreted as due to a lack of desired cultural homogeneity. But it's hard to make sense of anything at that level of generality. To push it a notch higher, I could say that wars are due to specific arrangements of atoms. I would be absolutely correct, but it wouldn't be helpful.
- Animats 11y agoThat was true up to about 1900 or so. But most wars since then have been an economic lose for the side that started them.