4 ms·
> But the real problem is just: too many people, period Why do you say that? Which resource is insufficient to support the current global population? (or even
by sangnoir 11y ago
> But the real problem is just: too many people, period
Why do you say that? Which resource is insufficient to support the current global population? (or even several times that)?
The problem is a lack of balance / poor management
- lisper 11y ago> Why do you say that? Which resource is insufficient to support the current global population? (or even several times that)? At the moment the limiting factor looks like it's going to be carbon emissions. But the real problem is that by the time we know for sure what the limiting factor is going to turn out to be it will be too late to do anything about it. > The problem is a lack of balance / poor management Balance? What kind of balance are you talking about? And what exactly would "better management" look like?
- sangnoir 11y ago> At the moment the limiting factor looks like it's going to be carbon emissions Carbon emissions can be (and have been) reduced without culling humans. Effective public transport infrastructure would do more for emissions than limiting the number of humans while still mostly commuting 1 vehicle per person. Alternative energy sources are also an effective solution which is independant on the size of the human population > Balance? What kind of balance are you talking about? Equitable trade and a little less nationalism & market protectionism. Farm subsidies and food donations (counter-intuitively) are destroying farming in developing countries > And what exactly would "better management" look like? * Less corruption by leadership, and literally "better management" there is more than enough food to feed every human on the planet, yet famines still happen. * leaders who take a long-term view on development (rather than focussing on the duration of their terms). Sustainable development will increase the quality of life * less corporatism/oligarchy/crony-capitalism and more people oriented governance which will lead to improved quality of life at the cost of (ill-gotten) profit. Social democracy appears to be a better way (IMO).
- lisper 11y ago> Carbon emissions can be (and have been) reduced without culling humans. Really? That's news to me. When did that happen? But before you answer, take a look at: http://cdiac.ornl.gov/trends/emis/glo_2011.html http://cdiac.ornl.gov/trends/emis/glo_2011.html > Effective public transport infrastructure OMG, where are you getting your information? Transportation only produces 25% of the world's carbon emissions, and most of that is industrial transport (trucking, shipping) and air travel and freight. Even if you got to 100% public transit across the globe that wouldn't make even a tiny dent. > Equitable trade > Less corruption How are those going to reduce carbon emissions? > Sustainable development Ah, there you have hit the nail on the head. How exactly are you going to do "sustainable development" in the face of an exponentially increasing population?
- sangnoir 11y ago> Really? That's news to me. When did that happen? Yes, really. Between the year 2007 and 2012 in the US. See [1]. > Even if you got to 100% public transit across the globe that wouldn't make even a tiny dent. I couldn't find the statistics for the US, but this Italian research paper[2] suggests 4% of CO2 emissions from Italy are from (low-occupancy) commuting. 100% public transit might lead to a 3% drop, which I consider much bigger than "a tiny dent". The US is likely to have a larger figure in absolute terms (greater average distances commuted, larger average engine bore, larger population). > How are those going to reduce carbon emissions? Nothing! I was answering a specific question you asked which was unrelated to carbon emissions. You question was quoted right before my answers, you couldn't have missed it. My overarching point is simply reducing the population will not guarantee a decrease in CO2 emissions. Have a look at [3], which shows the amount of CO2 per country. Lets' take the top 2: China emits twice the CO2 (10Gt) as the US (5Gt) with 4 times the population. (Assuming a linear correlation) if we were to half China's population and at the same time 'industrializing' it to same level as the US, then China's CO2 emissions wouldn't change > How exactly are you going to do "sustainable development" in the face of an exponentially increasing population? Same as always? Exponential population growth isn't a new phenomenon - take a look at the US population graph (1790-present) some time. 1. https://www.eia.gov/cfapps/ipdbproject/IEDIndex3.cfm?tid=90&pid=44&aid=8 https://www.eia.gov/cfapps/ipdbproject/IEDIndex3.cfm?tid=90&... 2. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/281447764_Commuting_carbon_dioxide_CO2_emissions_a_study_of_ten_Italian_metropolitan_cities https://www.researchgate.net/publication/281447764_Commuting... 3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...
- RivieraKid 11y ago> Which resource is insufficient to support the current global population? The Earth could support perhaps 10x or even 100x more people - but by support I mean that that amount of people would survive. The real question is how does quality of life depend on population and where's the optimum. When you have a small population (e.g. 10 million), the rate of research is slow, there are not many different products on the market (i.e. you can't choose from hundreds of cars to buy like today), etc. With a large population on the other hand, you have less resources per capita - water, oil, minerals, land, wood.
- NhanH 11y agoThe rate of research is orthogonal to quality of life. On an absolute timescale, yes you might reach more advancement faster, but also more people were living at the time without those advancement. So unless we are in a race with some aliens, it doesn't matter
- 13thLetter 11y ago> So unless we are in a race with some aliens, it doesn't matter It matters to the people who die early because we didn't develop a particular medical treatment. Just to pick a random example.
- NhanH 11y agoBut by having more people, you also have more people having more problems. In other word, the person who die early might not even exist at that year if the population was less. Instead of having an x population over y time span, you have an x/n population that span n*y period. My point was that you need to have some kind of metric (suffering per human per year?), or otherwise the "quality of life" across different population size and time span doesn't make sense.
- 13thLetter 11y agoSurely in that case the ideal number of humans is zero, because then there wouldn't be any human suffering. This is the logic of a mad artificial intelligence from a science fiction movie.
- mikeash 11y agoEcosystems, soil, water. http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/aug/12/humans-have-already-used-up-2015s-supply-of-earths-resources-analysis http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/aug/12/humans-ha...
- eximius 11y agoJust because we have enough resources for the current population today (or even the near future) does not mean that it is sustainable.
- sbierwagen 11y agoWhich resource is insufficient to support the current global population? Oil.
- DavidAdams 11y agoOne of the most pressing problems is sustainably arable land. The most productive farmland in the world has been progressively losing topsoil because our modern mechanized agriculture methods are wasteful. This topsoil was deposited over millions of years by wild grasslands, then eroded away over 150 years. And as the world's population grows, much of the remaining potentially productive farmland each year gets paved over by exurbs. http://world.time.com/2012/12/14/what-if-the-worlds-soil-runs-out/ http://world.time.com/2012/12/14/what-if-the-worlds-soil-run...
- Houshalter 11y agoStill, we have vastly more farm land than we technically need. Most of it goes to growing food for meat, which could be significantly reduced if there was a shortage. There is also tech on the horizon to produce food more efficiently, e.g. bacteria can produce sugar much more efficiently than sugar beets.
- jameslk 11y agoTo support the old, we need to have more young. It's a lot like a Ponzi scheme. It's an inherently unsustainable situation. Also, resources aren't the only concern of having more people. More people means more governance. The world becomes more complex as the numbers grow. Accountability becomes harder, laws become more extensive.