3 ms·
I don't think that's the way it worked. War resulted in a deficit of men, but it's not that kingdoms/nations went to war to reduce the number of men because it
by mc32 11y ago
I don't think that's the way it worked. War resulted in a deficit of men, but it's not that kingdoms/nations went to war to reduce the number of men because it was thought there were too many men.
- Mz 11y agoThe way it works is we take young men hopped up on testosterone and convince them that joining the military is a good idea for REASONS. Then we go to war due to "scarcity" of resources, which is the flip side of the coin of what people mean when they say "we have too many people." So, you can rearrange the semantics all you like, but he's essentially correct.
- mc32 11y agoPeople, kingdoms and nations went to war for many reasons, from oppression, to "marriages" among royals, land grabs, consolidation of power in order to have more political stability (fewer incursions from usurpers of the kingdom), affronts, insanity, etc. but I can't imagine many were due to "we have too many restless men" we need to concoct war, risk losing war and our people, because we have too many young men and we need culling because.... A standing army plus reserves and the population you could call up to fight is what kept enemies from wanting to invade.
- Mz 11y agoIf you actually study the history, the single most common reason that people go to war is due to a lack of resources of some sort. Food or something critical to the economy or whatever. (Edit: There are a MILLION explanations, but scarcity of resources or insufficient resources of some sort is almost always the actual root cause.) So, again: "There aren't enough resources" is essentially what people mean when they say "There are too many people." Sending people to war -- win, lose or draw -- tends to get the number of people down and may have long term impact on keeping the number down by removing the potential for those who died young on the field of battle to reproduce at all. You can claim all you like that "BUT, THAT isn't THE REASON we go to war" and, you know, it just makes me think you have no understanding of history. It doesn't convince me you are right.
- mc32 11y agoIf by men you mean people, ok. But he said too many "men". But its still backwards, its like when someone says, oh my food is too cold and you say, no, it's not too cold at all, it's simply not hot enough. Often times wars were fought for stability. If you were stronger the weaker adversaries would be less likely to wage war against you. So your going to war was more to counteract someone else's lack of resources who might fight for them rather than your need for resources... Anyhow it like saying we went to war because we wanted to live longer.... Ok. Yes, but that's not how we typically present the issue.
- Mz 11y agoSo your going to war was more to counteract someone else's lack of resources who might fight for them rather than your need for resources... This is causing me a blue screen of death moment. You are disagreeing with me by saying "But the war could start because of someone else's lack of resources..." and I cannot fathom how that is an argument against the idea that a lack of resources is almost always the root cause. So, I think I shall step away from this discussion now. Thank you.
- mc32 11y agoOne is cause the other effect.
- Alex3917 11y agoIf countries really started wars to reduce their populations, they'd send women to war instead of men.
- jhedwards 11y agoI remember reading about this very thing in Barbara Tuchman's "A distant Mirror". In medieval France there was a large number of bandits that looted the countryside and wreaked havoc wherever they went. The royalty would find some excuse to wage war and hire a general to round up the bandits and bring them away with promises of war bounty. In the scope of world history, though, this was probably not too common.
- dbpokorny 11y agoThis isn't quite correct; it should go > Then we go to war in order to make sure some other country can't create artificial scarcity of resources, which would reduce the number of people we have against our wishes It is about preventing someone else from cutting off your supply lines.
- anigbrowl 11y agoThey don't do it deliberately, but that's how it often happens. Even in tribal societies those with a surfeit of young men tend to start raiding neighboring tribes for women.
- deciplex 11y agoYeah, no chief or despot or king or prime minister ever took a nation or tribe to war with the explicit goal of reducing the number of young men in the population. However, when you have a bunch of extra young men looking for something to do, as opposed to a shortage of same (i.e. not enough of them to do the things that need doing), the opportunity cost of going to war also goes down. So nations with a surplus of young men are more likely to go to war.
- duaneb 11y agoYes, there are many factors. But too many men can increase aggressive restlessness.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoI am not sure about in which way it worked, but in some Plato writings (thousands of years ago), there were clear scenarios on population control. So perhaps kings have been advised to send the youth to war for this purpose.
- narrator 11y agoReading a lot of middle east ancient history, it's pretty easy to see the population pressure causing regular wars. In my opinion, Gilgamesh has a much milder tone than a lot of ancient history because it was nearer to the time when agriculture and walled cities were a new invention and the population pressures were much less severe.
- agumonkey 11y agoMaybe excess of immature and foolish yields too many opportunities for violent events to happen ?