8 ms·
Very misleading headline. It should be, "The world has a problem: too many young people in poor countries." Rich countries have the exact opposite problem: to
by lisper 11y ago
Very misleading headline. It should be, "The world has a problem: too many young people in poor countries." Rich countries have the exact opposite problem: too many old people.
But the real problem is just: too many people, period.
- Ygg2 11y agoI don't think that the problem is too many people. It's not enough, and not managed well enough.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoWhy would we need even more people? People will not get managed much better unless they are scarce.
- Mz 11y agoPeople will not get managed much better unless they are better educated. FTFY.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoPopulation of Russia is very educated but one of the worst mismanaged, for counterexample.
- sangnoir 11y agoWhy would we need even more money? Money will not get managed much better unless it is scarce.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoThis is true too. When there's too much money it blows a bubble.
- lisper 11y ago> It's not enough It's very hard to take you seriously if you make a bald assertion like that with no supporting arguments. It doesn't help that it's an assertion that, to me, seems absurd on its face. Seriously, how can anyone think there are not enough people? I would really like to know.
- zghst 11y agoI used to be in the camp of "there's not too many people" but then I look around and see how polluted and crowded it is all over the world and imagine 40 years later when there are 9 billion people contributing to the existing pollution and heavy burden on the infrastructure and environment. There are too many people.
- eru 11y agoThe Netherlands and England seem pleasant enough. The world as a whole is way below their population density numbers.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoThose benefit from a very very nice location: temperate weather, lots of rain, plains, sea shore. Compare that to Central Africa, North Siberia or most of Australia. There's no way to live there at comparable density without being miserable.
- eru 11y agoJust sprinkle two thousand Singapores around the world. No need to make Australia as dense as England.
- chiph 11y agoIn my own lifetime (I'm in my early 50's) the population of my home state of South Carolina has doubled (2.46mm to 4.89mm). Picking Oklahoma so I don't get criticized as cherry-picking the data (it's often described as a "flyover" state and isn't considered a migration destination), they have gone from 2.4mm to 3.8mm people in the same time. So they've grown as well, but not doubled. So unless you live in an area that is depopulating (Syria? Japan?), I think your assertion is incorrect.
- sangnoir 11y ago> But the real problem is just: too many people, period Why do you say that? Which resource is insufficient to support the current global population? (or even several times that)? The problem is a lack of balance / poor management
- lisper 11y ago> Why do you say that? Which resource is insufficient to support the current global population? (or even several times that)? At the moment the limiting factor looks like it's going to be carbon emissions. But the real problem is that by the time we know for sure what the limiting factor is going to turn out to be it will be too late to do anything about it. > The problem is a lack of balance / poor management Balance? What kind of balance are you talking about? And what exactly would "better management" look like?
- sangnoir 11y ago> At the moment the limiting factor looks like it's going to be carbon emissions Carbon emissions can be (and have been) reduced without culling humans. Effective public transport infrastructure would do more for emissions than limiting the number of humans while still mostly commuting 1 vehicle per person. Alternative energy sources are also an effective solution which is independant on the size of the human population > Balance? What kind of balance are you talking about? Equitable trade and a little less nationalism & market protectionism. Farm subsidies and food donations (counter-intuitively) are destroying farming in developing countries > And what exactly would "better management" look like? * Less corruption by leadership, and literally "better management" there is more than enough food to feed every human on the planet, yet famines still happen. * leaders who take a long-term view on development (rather than focussing on the duration of their terms). Sustainable development will increase the quality of life * less corporatism/oligarchy/crony-capitalism and more people oriented governance which will lead to improved quality of life at the cost of (ill-gotten) profit. Social democracy appears to be a better way (IMO).
- lisper 11y ago
- teslaberry 11y agothere are too many peasants for the oligarchy to control. stalin famously said about the chinese peasants that if mao did kill 100 million of them, it wouldn't be so bad. the problem is not too many people. not by a long shot. factually speaking, people could simply eat more veggies instead of eating livestock and the sheer number of acres and resources that frees up could sustain triple the number of people on the planet. the issue is about control of civilization, not about 'humans' existing. and the scary question to ask yourself is whether or not your value a certain type of future for humanity, or, whehter you simply value humanity, no matter what state or form civilization would take. would you trade a future high tech civilization with murder and occasional warfare and suffering for a future society living in the dark ages with quintuple the number of people. is 'more' people , better? just for its own sake. and this begs the quesiton, WHO GETS TO MAKE MORE PEOPLE? AND WHO GETS TO IMPOSE THE RULES AGAINST THOSE WHO ARE PROHIBITED TO MAKE MORE PEOPLE. it's all sounding very tyrannical isn't it. well, that's not an accident.