2 ms·
> Education as a remedy for social problems is a failed experiment. Education is simply one part. And education is actually one of the most cost effective. I
by bsder 11y ago
> Education as a remedy for social problems is a failed experiment.
Education is simply one part. And education is actually one of the most cost effective. I can't find the study, but for every year you can keep a child in school, the probability of their getting into criminal trouble drops by something like 15%.
> education is never going to fix inner cities victimized by historical segregation, deindustrialization, and social collapse.
You say this like it doesn't affect you. This is coming to us ALL. Deindustrialization and social collapse is rife in rural areas, too. It's why there are so many angry people in this US election.
If we don't figure this out, and soon, ALL of us are going to be in this same boat.
- rayiner 11y ago> You say this like it doesn't affect you. I say this as someone who has spent the last five years living or working in downtown New Rochelle, Wilmington, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and D.C. Each of these cities spends more (in some cases, a lot more) per pupil than the affluent suburb where I grew up. And it's not doing anything to help these kids. > If we don't figure this out, and soon, ALL of us are going to be in this same boat. We're not willing to do what it takes to fix the problem. What people keep voting for is separate but equal: give those 90% low-income minority school districts more and more money hoping that fixes things. Nobody is willing to put into place measures to actually integrate those populations into the broader community. Here's an idea: instead of creating urban ghettos by concentrating welfare spending in the inner cities, why not spread it out? Build housing projects in wealthy suburbs so kids can go to schools where their peers and the community put high value on education. Measures that might actually break the cycle of poverty are a total no-go even in "liberal" places.
- nitrogen 11y agoI think what you suggest (regarding integration) is in the right direction, but simply moving people around wouldn't be near enough. You will have opposition from all sides. You would have to limit your "integrations" to a very small percentage of the local population, or they would just bring their drug and gang problems with them. You have to deal with the accusation that you are trying to destroy a culture, be it farm culture, urban culture, ethnic culture, whatever. All in all, it seems like the current divisions in society have developed very strong memetic immunizations against thoughts of integration, and I don't see how you overcome that.
- merpnderp 11y ago"It's why there are so many angry people in this US election." Did you miss the last 12 years were people were lynching puppets of the sitting present (Bush protestors) or pooping on cops cars and shutting down large portions of inner cities (occupy protestors) or large segments of the country referring to a minority group of tax reformers as "tea-baggers"? By those standards, things are a lot more civil.