4 ms·
Americans like to believe that there exists some bright line between citizens and non-citizens. As a US lawyer, I'll tell you there is no such line. There are
by sandworm101 11y ago
Americans like to believe that there exists some bright line between citizens and non-citizens. As a US lawyer, I'll tell you there is no such line. There are dozens of different classes of citizenship, each with a unique set of rights. These kids are at the bottom of that list.
The world is most aware of the two highest-level citizenship classes, specifically the line between natural and naturalized citizens. The former is the higher, with the later not being allowed certain high offices (ie being president) and that their citizenship can be stripped. The next set of lines is between citizens of states (Ohio et al) and those residing in non-states such as DC, Guam and like territories. Such non-state citizens have various subset voting right depending on local. Some cannot serve on juries.
The next line down are people like convicted felons (non-voting) children (can be forced into delinquency proceedings) and members of the military (subject to different laws/courts). Some jurists would even list males as a subset since, unlike females, males are subject to selective service rules and can therefore be forced into the previous class.
At the bottom of this pile are these kids. Non-state non-citizens, under-age without guardians, the are treated like chattel (property). Their deportation proceedings read like the comical cases brought against property seized at boarder crossings (civil forfeiture). But even non-sentient objects, specifically guns, sometimes have the right to representation. Any US person facing criminal conviction is due adequate representation, but not facing criminal action and not being a citizen of any state or territory, the US justice system has little respect for these kids.
Don't like it? There is an election coming up.
- jack9 11y agoThere's one citizen type in-between the natural and naturalized (and below), it's the natural citizen in a US Territory. No votes for you. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CesHr99ezWE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CesHr99ezWE
- sandworm101 11y agoYup. I did some quick notes and stopped after ten different classes. There are certainly dozens.
- tarikjn 11y agoGlad you point this out, there is also the difference between nationality and citizenship, discussed on this article: http://www.ascotadvisory.com/US-Citizenship-Renouncement.html http://www.ascotadvisory.com/US-Citizenship-Renouncement.htm...
- saganus 11y ago> But even non-sentient objects, specifically guns, sometimes have the right to representation Wait. What? Do you have any links for more info on this? I can't even start to imagine what does it even mean for an object to have legal representation. Is this something known to happen in other countries (i.e. this is an artifact due to complex interaction inside legal systems) or just in the US?
- antognini 11y agoI believe GP is referring to asset forfeiture. Asset forfeiture is a legal fiction in which objects associated with a crime are charged. So if drug dealer was transacting drug deals in his car, the government could seize the car and charge the car with a crime. The owner would then have to try to represent the car and prove the car's innocence in the crime. But because asset forfeiture is normally a civil proceeding, the burden of proof is much lower for the government (preponderance of the evidence rather than proof beyond a reasonable doubt). So even if the owner was found not guilty of the original crime, the asset can still be found "guilty" and seized. Here's a good flowchart on the rules that the owner must go through (at the federal level) to win their assets back: http://reason.com/assets/mc/2015_06/forfeitchart.jpg http://reason.com/assets/mc/2015_06/forfeitchart.jpg These two Wikipedia articles have more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_rem_jurisdiction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_rem_jurisdiction
- saganus 11y agoThanks a lot for the info. I've heard about asset forfeiture before, but I had no idea it worked that way. Seems a bit insane that you can charge objects with crimes.
- sandworm101 11y agoThere are several jurisdictions that forbid cops from destroying seized weapons. They must be sold to the public or used by police. In a couple of these jurisdictions, if they really want to destroy the weapons they need a court order. Getting that court order requires a hearing at which "the guns" are represented by an attorney. I haven't witnessed such a proceeding, but theoretically the state may have to provide that attorney. I presume the NRA could also stand in. So yes, inanimate objects can sometimes have more of a right to representation by an attorney than these actual human children.