4 ms·
These articles are really getting tired. What people seem to continously miss is that there is no objective "quality" standard. Value to YOU is not the same as
by manigandham 11y ago
These articles are really getting tired. What people seem to continously miss is that there is no objective "quality" standard. Value to YOU is not the same as to someone else. While we can all subjectively say stuff like celebrity news isnt as important as the latest scientific breakthrough, people are free to, and will, read whatever they want to read - and it's their actions that determines what content holds value to them.
Now, regardless of quality, all that content does cost money to create and advertising is a great system to subsidize those costs. It's fast, passive, egalitarian, and efficient compared to any form of direct payment (where funds are transferred directly from you to the site). Giving the reader the choice is of course the best option, but short of that, it's far better to have ads then closed access.
The problem today isn't advertising the system but rather the implementation - it's the low barriers to entry, weak standards, lack of regulation or any enforcement and misaligned incentives that has caused this massive proliferation of crappy ad networks with bad code, scammy ads, malware and fraud.
Acceptable ads is absolutely the right start, it just needs to be done by an industry group or even the FTC/government itself so that it holds some power. Not an adblocking company that is paid to whitelist because clearly this leads to a conflict of interest as can be seen in what is already let through. Combine real regulation with a vetted list of approved vendors who do the right thing that advertisers are only allowed to use and we can finally move on from this silly war between readers and ads.
- voidz 11y agoMmmm nope. Not buying into it. Sorry.
- manigandham 11y agoNot buying what? I'm not selling anything. It would help if you had some objections that you could list.
- a_imho 11y agoComparing ads to direct payments is false dichotomy, there are countless other ways to monetize content. Also, most ads as we know are not fast nor passive. Imho content blocking is just a harsh realization your content not worth as much you thought until you could force everyone to pay for it through ads, and now you have to play catch up. Let the market handle it.
- manigandham 11y agoNot really. When you get to fundamentals, it's either: - direct payment (subscriptions, micropayments, donations, anything that involves you directly transferring funds) - indirect (ads or another 3rd party subsidizing like the BBC by the UK government, which is just funded through taxes though so it might just be direct anyway) That is the dichotomy and there's nothing false about it. > Also, most ads as we know are not fast nor passive. It seems you're referring to implementation problem I mentioned, nothing wrong with the concept of advertising itself. By fast and passive, I'm talking about the lack of decisioning needed to determine the actual monetary value of something. Figuring out whether you want to purchase every single page view will quickly cause mental friction far beyond the attention that ads take. > Imho content blocking is just a harsh realization your content not worth as much you thought until you could force everyone to pay for it through ads I dont understand how content blocking changes the value of the content. The fact that you are consuming it means that you attribute value to it. Nobody is being forced though so if you don't find it valuable or you think the ads demand too much attention in exchange then you are free to stop reading that content.
- a_imho 11y agoI feel there are some concepts washed together, e.g micropayments need not be direct in any way, and meaning a 3rd party subsidizing might just regarded as direct is false imho. >Figuring out whether you want to purchase every single page view will quickly cause mental friction far beyond the attention that ads take. Depends what you sell by the piece. Publishers do this with research papers, no problem. Or if you sell a stream for an event, go ahead. If you want to split your latest top10 diets to 10 pages, sure, you will have problems. Subscriptions might work for that. Again, there are many ways depending on your business, lets not paint it all the same color. >I dont understand how content blocking changes the value of the content. It does not. It presents a more accurate valuation by giving direct control to your users. It works both ways, imagine you have a paywall and no ads and your revenues start to skyrocket. But somehow very few sites are bold enough to take that bet. Presenting the invasive nature of ads as an implementation problem feels a bit dishonest to me, as we have all the tools necessary to make them less obtrusive. See popups/modals. They are made to be that way and to me is clearly a design decision. Still we just have to wait how things unfold, it is up to the content providers to react to blockers gaining popularity.
- DavideNL 11y agoI don't agree with this.. I compare the internet ad situation with my TV (in the Netherlands): since about 10 years there's been more and more ads on many channels, and i stopped watching at ALL of them. There are currently about 5 channels (of 100+ total) that i still watch, the ones without ads. And I don't mis much because in my opinion most of the commercial TV channels (the ones with ads) also have low quality content. I really hope ad blocking keeps growing and all the bad quality content on the internet dies together with the ads. And i'll hapily pay for quality internet content without ads, at an acceptible price, just as i buy apps in Apples appstore, and pay for Netflix.
- manigandham 11y agoI'm not sure what part you don't agree with... If you don't feel the ads are worth the content in exchange, then you are free to stop consuming that content. Which is exactly what you're doing. Again, there's no "bad" quality content. Bad to you might be what someone else is interested in. As for everything else, it's just an implementation problem with the market being flooded with shady advertisers and ad networks that operate without oversight. TV/radio/print all have much stricter standards which is sorely missing online. Paying for content is a perfectly acceptable system, it's just not as scalable or equal to all users as ads are. Payments are a valid option, but it's far better to be a choice rather than the only option compared to advertising.
- kuschku 11y ago> Again, there's no "bad" quality content. But that’s wrong. There is content that has purely no content, and which is engineered to make people click, despite providing no benefit. Think about all the Buzzfeed upvoted etc sites, providing next to no benefit at all.
- manigandham 11y agoThose sites are read by lots of people who do like that content. Content is content, you can't just engineer constant attention without actually producing anything. The fact is that the mainstream does like reading what Buzzfeed puts out and are getting plenty of value/benefit from it - regardless of your subjective judgement of it.