3 ms·
All ZFS contributions before the illumos split were assigned to Oracle because they had a CLA with all contributors. I'd still argue they definitely have copyri
by cyphar 11y ago
All ZFS contributions before the illumos split were assigned to Oracle because they had a CLA with all contributors. I'd still argue they definitely have copyright ownership (the current source is based on the original files, no doubt about it).
- protomyth 11y agoHow would Oracle own the code written without the CLA? That doesn't make any sense.
- cyphar 11y agoThey don't own the current code, but all contributions are based on diffs on the original code. The contributors own their changes, but not the code as a whole. I don't believe that it's ever been tested in court how many incremental changes are enough to remove the original copyright owners' copyright claims. Especially when it comes to something like ZFS where there are data structures that were designed a long time ago and they must be kept (as well as the code for handling them) for backwards compatibility essentially indefinitely.
- protomyth 11y agoThe issue isn't removing the original copyright holders claim. No one is saying that's possible. Oracle is free to relicense the code they own at any time, but that relicense doesn't affect the code written by others and Oracle does not have rights to that code unless they had a CLA. The new OpenZFS code is not under a CLA.