4 ms·
What I would be curious to know is how many of these 268 samples do not have a matching DNA. "Scientifically invalid" is a bit vague. Does that mean that the sa
by cm2187 11y ago
What I would be curious to know is how many of these 268 samples do not have a matching DNA. "Scientifically invalid" is a bit vague. Does that mean that the samples were not a match or does that mean that the method used didn't provide a sufficient degree of confidence of a match?
- walid 11y agoIt doesn't matter if "scientifically invalid" is a vague because when the jury decides based on invalid hair sample analysis then justice is not served. Also some evidence collection might not yield DNA in the first place.
- Someone 11y agoThis isn't about DNA analysis, it is about staring through a microscope, comparing hairs. Quote: "At trial, the prosecution relied on the testimony of the three informants as well as the testimony of Elinos Whitlock III, an employee of the Charlotte Mecklenburg Police Department Crime Lab who had been trained by the FBI in how to conduct microscopic hair analysis. He claimed that he could make a “strong identification” that a hair recovered the crime scene was Bridges’s hair. He further stated that there was only a 1 in 1000 chance that two Caucasian people (Bridges is white) would have indistinguishable head hair."
- cm2187 11y agoI know the analysis isn't about DNA, but DNA gives us a way to validate the analysis. When a defense lawyer uses words like scientifically invalid, it is designed to make it look like the analysis is just bullocks, but most likely it is something much more subtile, like a different confidence interval, or something like that.