3 ms·
[E]verything we hold of value—metals, minerals, energy and real estate— [is available] in near-infinite quantities in space. Yes, and there is a pot o' gold at
by patio11 17y ago
[E]verything we hold of value—metals, minerals, energy and real estate— [is available] in near-infinite quantities in space.
Yes, and there is a pot o' gold at the end of every rainbow. A pity you have to bring it back here to be able to get any use out of it. If there were a pot o' gold in earth orbit and I had a space shuttle ready to go up and snag it I'd be better off canceling the launch, letting the gold rot, and pocketing the money saved. It doesn't matter if that pot o' gold were the size of an aircraft carrier.
How long before bored billionaires figure out that being on a souped-up jet with sucky cabin service has lost its $X-million-a-pop "story you can brag about to your friends" cachet, and we actually have to start extracting value out of space? Private industry is then going to go back to exploiting space via the only thing we can move without incurring fuel & etc costs: data, via satellites.
- jerf 17y agoI think you either grossly underestimate the value of gold or overestimate the cost of a flight. (Or have a really, really weird idea about economics and when you've made a profit.) Besides, even if you think you're better off sitting on your ass, that doesn't mean everyone will, or should. But your point is irrelevant, because we need those minerals anyhow. Remember the people who point out that we don't have enough platinum on Earth to make enough fuel cells for cars (and other things), or enough rare earths for other worthy green technologies? The value of those minerals is going up over time as we deplete our supply, the costs of spaceflight will go down. The question is when those curves cross, not if. There are some things that we can do a lot better with those resources that just "sitting on Earth" is not going to be a economically viable alternative to.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 17y agoGold is a weird case, in that we don't actually have much practical use for gold. Some, sure (electrical contacts and such), but the vast majority of its value is circular: it's valuable because people perceive it to be a safe store of value, and therefore lots of it is held in vaults. A sudden discovery of a way to get large quantities of gold to earth could cause its value to totally collapse to near-nothing.
- yannis 17y agoBesides the actual use of gold being minimal - most of the gold dug up since Roman times is still around in one form or other.
- jerf 17y agoYeah, that's why I switched to discussing platinum. Not only is it generically useful, it's even useful strictly from a "we need to learn to live on Earth first" sense. We don't have enough for known green technologies.
- w1ntermute 17y agoA pity you have to bring it back here to be able to get any use out of it. Well, if people are living in space, I'd wager that the transport costs could be drastically reduced.