3 ms·
>>> "speed will be regulated at the law." That doesn't need robot drivers. That is and can be deployed today. Why it isn't ... that's an open question. >>>
by sandworm101 11y ago
>>> "speed will be regulated at the law."
That doesn't need robot drivers. That is and can be deployed today. Why it isn't ... that's an open question.
>>> "the truck driving software can always make the decision in favor of the other drivers on the road"
I've really wondered about this. Wouldn't software that acts like a jerk (ie not letting people in etc) be more valuable if it gets from A to B faster? Why think that the same pressures that force drivers to act like jerks won't also be applied to software?
- anexprogrammer 11y agoUK trucks, at least, have had mandatory 60mph limiters for probably 30 years. Was lowered to 56mph (90 kmh) to match speeds with Europe at some point.
- sandworm101 11y agoBut are they also automatically limited to 10/20/30 depending on the road? That tech has also been around for decades. Manufacturers haven't even attempted to market it.
- toyg 11y ago> That doesn't need robot drivers. You're right, it needs robot enforcers :) > Why think that the same pressures that force drivers to act like jerks won't also be applied to software? They will; but a human can improvise and lie, whereas software can (in theory) be audited and tested. The software will be built by manufacturers, not lorry owners; and they don't want to end up on the wrong side of car regulators -- see the recent VW affair.
- sandworm101 11y ago>> ..see the recent VW affair. You mean shrewdly duping regulators year after year so they can sell more cars, make more money, enrich shareholders, and become a market leader? No matter what the cost today, I think VW shareholders would rather they have done what they did as opposed to giving up the market to competitors. (They all seem to have been playing tricks imho.)
- mmanfrin 11y agoWouldn't software that acts like a jerk (ie not letting people in etc) be more valuable if it gets from A to B faster? Why think that the same pressures that force drivers to act like jerks won't also be applied to software? Because with human drivers, a human is liable for failures. With software, the company is liable. If the software thinks "this is a dangerous situation", it will be written to defer to not causing injury, because there's really no way the contents of a truck are going to be worth more than the cost of paying out $x millions in the case of killing a human.
- sandworm101 11y ago>> With software, the company is liable. Check the fine print on your windows license. Then check the fine print on any aerospace autopilot. They disclaim everything. It's always the operators responsibility, never the manufacturers unless of a serious defect. >> no way the contents of a truck are going to be worth more than the cost of paying out $x millions in the case of killing a human. If that were true all sorts of other safety devices would already be on trucks, starting with gps-enabled speed regulators. There is always a cost-benefit analysis. That includes tradeoffs between utility and safety.
- mmanfrin 11y agoYou are missing my meaning. By 'software', I mean the software that runs the self-driving trucks; both the companies building and using self-driving trucks could and would be liable, no matter what is 'in the fine print'. There is no operator, so blame has to go somewhere. There are already safety devices on trucks, but since there is a human operator, much of the onus of using or installing those is on the human, not the truck manufacturer or trucking company; and again, you're missing my point that with no driver, the liability falls to the producers of the self-driving software.
- sandworm101 11y ago>> with no driver, the liability falls to the producers of the self-driving software. Not really. The owner of the truck is also the operator. Trucking companies are sued for damages caused by their drivers every day. If a truck company chooses to use particular software, as they choose a particular driver, the trucking company will be liable. They are the one that decided to put the vehicle on the road. That's why they must carry insurance and why that insurance attaches to the vehicle regardless of who is driving it on a particular day. Swapping out an employee-driver for a robot won't change the situation. Even a truck that is stolen, a truck driven by someone the operator doesn't want behind the wheel, can result in liability should the operator not have taken reasonable steps to guard against theft.
- newjersey 11y ago> I've really wondered about this. Wouldn't software that acts like a jerk (ie not letting people in etc) be more valuable if it gets from A to B faster? Why think that the same pressures that force drivers to act like jerks won't also be applied to software? This makes me think of VW. > Winterkorn blamed "the terrible mistakes of a few people," whom he did not name, for the international scandal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Winterkorn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Winterkorn Now, to be clear I am not saying that Google's or Alphabet's CEO should go to jail. Rather the CEO of the company who owns the fleet should. Claiming that they didn't know what their employees did should not be allowed as a defense. Yes, I am still mad at VW for throwing their software engineers under the bus here. I don't know what the solution is but it can't be to just say "well, the software engineers knew what they were doing and they should have said no when told to implement something illegal" (this is what I understand Uncle Bob suggested).
- misnome 11y ago> Wouldn't software that acts like a jerk (ie not letting people in etc) be more valuable if it gets from A to B faster? Because the software - Isn't getting paid by the time taken, so isn't more expensive to take longer - Trucks can be more fuel efficient at slower speeds - Most truck shipping won't be so urgent that time matters beyond "Predictable arrival time".