7 ms·
As a fellow ex-Oracle (although a coalface support minion coming through an acquisition), and with all due respect, I downvoted your comment because it looks li
by toyg 11y ago
As a fellow ex-Oracle (although a coalface support minion coming through an acquisition), and with all due respect, I downvoted your comment because it looks like a bit of an incoherent rant with no apparent link to the post.
What Rhaman is saying is: the wide Java portfolio is dying because people are not making enough waves around the JCP to keep Oracle on the straight and narrow. Nothing to do with opensource, the JCP is a very different project from traditional opensource development.
The JRE has never been a "real" open source project, but rather a proprietary system that opened up enough to develop a caring community. The problem is that, at the moment, the interests of Java's owner are not aligned with the interests of such community, and not enough people seem to care.
This has nothing to do with Java being "open source" or not; in fact, a real OSS project would happily fork at this point (as it happened with OpenOffice), but the Java community cannot really do it. It seems pointless to debate the merits of OSS in a situation where there is no OSS; it's like saying "We supported Windows out of self-interest; but let's talk about the pros and cons of opensource...".
- pron 11y ago> The JRE has never been a "real" open source project What does that mean? Compare Java to other open source projects of similar magnitude (and there aren't many; maybe only Linux, which is actually bigger). Linux is even more exclusive than OpenJDK, and just like Linux, companies with appropriate resources often make changes to the software even if those changes aren't contributed back (or contributed but not merged). > and not enough people seem to care People will care once many start to actually feel it. Oracle's interests are probably not aligned with mine, and may or may not be a cause for concern for me, but so far Oracle's actions wrt OpenJDK don't harm me at all. The investment in the platform feels to have only grown in the past few years. > but the Java community cannot really do it Why not? I think it most certainly can, but at this point there's not enough motivation to do it.
- toyg 11y agoLook at what Oracle is doing to Google for the sin of refusing the JCP process. Do you think they wouldn't do the same against any Java fork with a realistic chance of supplanting their implementation? The details are not important, they'll throw the book at you and find something that sticks. The current situation (OpenJDK open but not a realistic choice in most production deployments; Oracle JDK/JRE remaining as de-facto gold standard; a process that forces strict compatibility tests on any competitor) can be fine from a certain point of view, but in practice it means that Java is not a traditional community-led OSS program. Rather, it's a program where the OSS community helps a company improve their software. RedHat is not the only Linux build with significant marketshare, and I won't get sued if I write a different POSIX system. > at this point there's not enough motivation to do it. No there isn't, that's what Rhaman is saying. But what he's also implying is that the direction of travel has changed inside Oracle, and people outside do not seem to realize it. IMHO it's fairly obvious where things are going (you'll stop "installing Java", and only develop and deploy in the Oracle cloud or similar Oracle-sanctioned environments).
- the_af 11y ago> OpenJDK open but not a realistic choice in most production deployments This is news to me. I'm aware there are differences, but "not a realistic choice"? Can you elaborate?
- NotSammyHagar 11y agoI think openjdk is used in production. It's even going to be used in android in the future. You are incorrect that openjdk is not production ready today.
- the_af 11y agoI didn't claim it wasn't production ready, the parent post did.
- toyg 11y ago> It's even going to be used in android in the future. Lol, like that was a choice Google made freely, rather than something they were forced to do. OpenJDK might be OK in many circumstances (as I said, requirements vary) but you might want to avoid that particular case study.
- the_af 11y agoI'm going to be blunt: you claimed "OpenJDK [is] not a realistic choice in MOST production environments" (emphasis mine). I asked for evidence for this bold claim, since many production environments I know are using OpenJDK successfully, under heavy loads and without crashing. So... evidence of your claim?
- lovelearning 11y agoCan you elaborate on why OpenJDK is not suitable for production deployments? I thought Oracle's JDK/JRE were based on OpenJDK's, with only minor changes.
- 11y ago
- pjmlp 11y agoI went through a similar experience with Clipper and Turbo Pascal/Delphi, both were widely used and we thought they would last forever. When doubts started to appear 20 years ago, companies slowly moved their new projects to other stacks. They are still around and have been updated to more recent versions, but it hardly matters to most devs. Oracle being careless with mobile OSes support and bringing out stupid enterprise frameworks like Oracle Mobile Application Framework, has made people even go back to C++ for writing portable code for mobile OSes.
- chillaxtian 11y agowould someone mind explaining, or linking to an explanation, of what bits of Java are open source, and which aren't? phrased another way, which bits are missing that prevent an individual from compiling and running Java programs on the JVM using open source software.
- pjmlp 11y ago- Some parts of tha JavaFX pipeline are different - ARM compilers are different - The Swing font engine used to be different - Tooling that many devs depend on, like the Mission Control - The AOT native compilers and tooling for embedded Java Not an exhaustive list.
- needusername 11y agoOpenJDK is fully open source. Oracle JDK is built on OpenJDK but changes a few things here and there. * Oracle JDK has a different font rasteriser, maybe some other bits like sound are different as well * Oracle JDK has Flight Recorder support (that's a commercial feature) * Oracle JDK supports both C1 and C2 JITs on ARM64, AFAIK an open source implementation of this is coming to OpenJDK 9, likely Oracle JDK will keep the existing implementation * Oracle JDK has additional commercial features like resource management [2] and application class data sharing OpenJDK vanilla is AFAIK not TCK-certified. However there are TCK-certified OpenJDK distributions [3]. TL;DR: OpenJDK is fully open source [1] https://docs.oracle.com/javacomponents/ https://docs.oracle.com/javacomponents/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WZpmylHbFM&index=8&list=PLX8CzqL3ArzUo2dtMurvpUTAaujPMeuuU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WZpmylHbFM&index=8&list=PLX... [3] https://www.azul.com/products/zulu/ https://www.azul.com/products/zulu/
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The JRE has never been a "real" open source project It is real open source. Its not a community-driven bazaar-model development effort, but that doesn't define "real open source" (its just something enabled by, but not required for, open source.)
- john-waterwood 11y ago> The problem is that, at the moment, the interests of Java's owner are not aligned with the interests of such community, and not enough people seem to care. There's two ways to not care: 1. I don't care if it goes away, since who uses that stuff anyway? 2. I don't want to invest anything to further the project, but I really like using it and it's crucial for my business! At this point I think the latter is the problem.