4 ms·
It's not specific to gay marriage, but I think we ought to remove government recognition of all marriages. It codifies assumptions about lifestyle that we don'
by CalRobert 11y ago
It's not specific to gay marriage, but I think we ought to remove government recognition of all marriages. It codifies assumptions about lifestyle that we don't need to accept as norm.
- DanBC 11y ago...or split out religious marriages from state recognised marriages. If a religious bigot wants to discriminate against gay people, well, that's not great but up to them. When the state wants to discriminate against gay people that's worse, especially since "right to a family life" is a human right.
- skylan_q 11y agoIf a homosexual bigot wants to discriminate against christians, well, that's not great but up to them. When the state wants to discriminate against christians, that's worse, especially since "right to family life" is a human right. Oh wait, that's already happening and it's got a court ruling backing it: http://www.wsj.com/articles/court-rules-baker-cant-refuse-to-make-wedding-cake-for-gay-couple-1439506296 http://www.wsj.com/articles/court-rules-baker-cant-refuse-to...
- jazzyk 11y agoNo, the ruling is about treating every human being equally. Regardless of their religion, skin color, facial features, hair color, etc. Who is the "homosexual bigot" in your example? The judge practicing the law of the country ? Per U.S. Declaration of Independence, "All men are created equal".
- CalRobert 11y agoComments like the last few are a great reminder of why maybe the government shouldn't be prescribing a particular sort of relationship as ideal. If you don't like gay marriage, that's great, don't get one! Go to a church that doesn't recognize them! If you do like gay marriage, cool - go get one! Either way, call yourself married! Or not! Fortunately the government can recognize things like shared decision making, inheritance, property ownership, etc. without having to recognize that some people held a ceremony and a party and others didn't.
- marcoperaza 11y agoYou can only have equality before the law. The civil rights laws from the 60s were only justified due to the extraordinary nature of systemic and pervasive discrimination, which state governments encouraged and mandated since the end of slavery, in the South towards Black Americans. Unfortunately, what was then viewed as an extraordinary measure for an extraordinary situation, has now been expanded to every group imaginable and is now being used as a tool of social triumphalism. There is no crisis where gay couples are unable to find wedding bakers and photographers willing to serve them. I personally have no problem with homosexuality and gay marriage. But someone with religious convictions against it, should not be compelled to be involved. It's totally wrong to force a devout Christian photographer to participate in a gay wedding if he is opposed. What entitles you to his labor?
- DanBC 11y ago> There is no crisis where gay couples are unable to find wedding bakers and photographers willing to serve them. ...partly because laws were introduced to prevent discrimination by people offering commercial services.
- marcoperaza 11y agoI don't think this is the case. Social acceptance has preceded these laws; not the other way around.
- skylan_q 11y agoI've yet to see anyone pro-ssm get behind this kind of thinking, even though it is completely fair and rational to all groups. They want the state involved and for the state to define marriage so as to make it unfair to those who don't believe what they believe. i.e. "Marriage is just a couple who love each other" vs. other traditional beliefs.
- CalRobert 11y agoWell, I'm pro-ssm and I advocate this kind of thinking. Pragmatic me thinks: "It's kind of weird that we encode the idea of two adults sharing a home, family, and bed to the exclusion of other models, but IF we're going to do that we should let gay and straight couples do so" Idealistic me thinks: "Why the hell does the government recognize marriage anyway? People arrange their lives in dozens of different ways. A person can coparent/cohabit/have sex with/share medical choices with/share financial choices with/(etc.) a number of different partners, but we've decided "two adults doing all of those things is the norm, and anything else is less than ideal", which is a bit stifling. There are other models. Maybe the Mosuo "walking marriage" should become a codified norm instead?
- dllthomas 11y agoThis, loosely, describes my views as well.
- marcoperaza 11y agoI agree. It seems like most of features of legal marriage can be captured through contract law.
- azinman2 11y agoTax law isn't that way, as are many defaults for how things work. Previously many days did in fact go through very complicated legal proceedings to try and do this, but many places where it matters (like hospitals) don't have those contracts so its very different from just saying 'thats my husband/wife'. I think that's the more important bit -- having society recognize the relationship as equally valid, such that all the things that normal straight married people take for granted can also be taken for granted by gays. Unless law codifies that, it's harder to do. Civil rights has often focused on law as a kind of behavior floor and codification of rights -- society then takes many years to catch up but its a very motivating factor.
- marcoperaza 11y agoThe answer is to generalize any such legal privileges such that people can make their own arrangements as they see fit.