4 ms·
Yes. They're both about harming and dividing people in the name of irrational beliefs supported by their emotions. These beliefs in the past even led to consens
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Yes. They're both about harming and dividing people in the name of irrational beliefs supported by their emotions. These beliefs in the past even led to consensuses of imprisonment, beatings, and murders. If Eich merely had an opinion, I'd just disagree with it and say let him keep doing his good work. Putting money into active attacks on Americans' liberties, including his own employees/contributors, is totally different. Keep him or get rid of him is a grey area for me where I'm not decided on morale superiority of either yet. It could have wide-ranging effects in other areas of political participation.
Nonetheless, eliminating the wallet of someone paying to split you from your lover seems like self-defense rather than an attack. Their reaction was justified to say the least. The real evil here is the consistent trend of one group of people trying to limit another they disagree with. Let them be them, us be us, whatever so long as no provable harm is happening. That's my baseline for civil liberties.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoBy your standard, everyone who supported Obama should be fired, given that he also opposed gay marriage in 2008. You okay with that?
- jazzyk 11y agoYou missed his/her point - I don't think Obama donated money to the people opposing gay marriage.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoI don't think I missed the point at all. Are you seriously arguing that a donation to a statewide ballot issue has more wide-reaching influence than a donation to the President of the entire country? Obama didn't have to "donate money". He's the one getting donations for making the policy, not the one giving money to influence it.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoObama is supposed to act as an agent of his constituents and a leader at the same time. His constituents are tens of to 100+ million Americans with a variety of demands. He has to vote or act their way a good amount of time to get or stay elected. It's very constrained and dirty due to inherently corrupt environment between cost of elections (excludes good folks, promotes lobbying) and tyranny of majority. System and demand side are problem because they exclude all honest, decent people from President. Name a counterexample in past two decades if you doubt that. So, Presidents and often (not always) Congress are a special situation compared to a group voluntarily creating organizatikns to push for harm and people supporting that over better organizations. Totally different in both what options are available to people starting nonprofits and which people can donate to vs what specific actions a President or Congress can pull off.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThe other commenter figured it out. Eich donated to a group specifically about causing gay people harm. You can either ignore someone financing harm or punish them as deterrence. Many chose to punish. Now, Obama is a dirty politician people chose over more honest runners. His claims and voting record mismatched early enough to know. Electing scumbags is another kind of harm. People can ignore or react to that too. Far as politicians, supporting certain types of laws is a requirement for election given how voters act in this country. So, I'd make an exception there where I wouldn't fire prople but you could boycott their business or state if you wanted.
- Turing_Machine 11y ago"Far as politicians, supporting certain types of laws is a requirement for election given how voters act in this country." Got it. Claiming to support laws that you actually think are wrong is excusable if it means you can get elected. You're basically saying that Obama lied to get elected, and that you're okay with that. That doesn't really come off quite the way I think you intended.