4 ms·
Did you find out why? Were any of them burned by bad webapp interfaces? Were any of them burned by their webapp getting an "unwelcome update?" Were any of them
by stcredzero 11y ago
Did you find out why? Were any of them burned by bad webapp interfaces? Were any of them burned by their webapp getting an "unwelcome update?" Were any of them burned by crappy behavior under limited connectivity? (That one has happened to me a lot with web apps on an iPhone.)
I suspect that the problems of small app developers are much the same as guys on dating sites. All of the discoverability is implemented and controlled by one entity who doesn't depend on your success specifically to make money. They only need just enough success to keep the whole thing running.
I wish now that Jobs had gotten his way in the beginning, and all of the apps would be web apps, and discoverability would be through web links and search engines.
- nostrademons 11y agoI'd toyed with the idea of doing an app discoverability startup (for Android...Google is not as averse to alternative discovery mechanisms as Apple) and even done some market research, and prospects did not look good. The root cause was that mobile phone users don't even think in terms of "discoverability" - they use a new app when they hear about it from a friend or read about it on a blog, and it fills some hole in the life that's pretty painful. No hole = no app usage. It's not like with Web 2.0, where people were actively seeking out idle diversions to use up their spare time while they sit at their do-nothing jobs. Now, everybody has been laid off from their do-nothing jobs, and they're actively seeking ways to better their circumstances, and if your app doesn't fit into that plan they aren't interested. As much as I wish Apple & Google would fix the discoverability problem, I'm not sure it would help much. Discoverability today means finding a crucial pain point and then going out, yourself, engaging customers and explaining how your solution helps them accomplish their goals. There are still profitable niches out there, but you have to do the work of building an actual business and not just an app.
- aikah 11y ago> I wish now that Jobs had gotten his way in the beginning, and all of the apps would be web apps The IPhone ecosystem would be nowhere near what it is today if not for native apps. It would have been a serious mistake. People want native apps because the mobile web sucks for anything a bit more complex than displaying text or simple forms. And web APIs on mobile in general still suck. Caching sucks, The DOM is still slow and cannot deeply interact with phone features or hardware. The mobile web has failed since native apps are still required. Every web tech base mobile OS have failed. Firefox OS for mobile has failed.
- neotek 11y agoI imagine that if all apps were web apps, then we'd have solved all of the issues you mention. Necessity is the mother of invention, etc.
- aikah 11y agoWe wouldn't have solved anything due to limitations of the web stack. There is no way to make it run fast on a $100 handset. The native stack on the other hand can run pretty fast on low hand devices.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoPeople want native apps because the mobile web sucks for anything a bit more complex than displaying text or simple forms. Which is exactly what most apps (not games) do.
- pcwalton 11y agoThis is a problem with browsers, not with the mobile Web technologies. Browsers are designed with a legacy, slow architecture. This can change without changing the Web APIs much, if at all. Native technology stacks aren't really that great either, and I think that native has some fundamental disadvantages when it comes to performance, especially around graphics.
- hellbanner 11y agoWell, one of them didn't know that you could "download" a shortcut with the add to home screen, for example. In my experience it's a trend -- "we want an app" because "apps are cool".