6 ms·
"You can teach everyone to be a great programmer" Flat out dead wrong. If you hire "anyone" and try to teach them to be a programmer then you will probably fi
by andrewstuart 11y ago
"You can teach everyone to be a great programmer"
Flat out dead wrong. If you hire "anyone" and try to teach them to be a programmer then you will probably fire them.
This is the sort of attitude that leads companies to outsource their development overseas: "Our programmers are people hitting keys. We'll get overseas people to hit keys and overseas people hit keys for less money.", cause, you know, anyone can do it.
Programming is VERY hard and it takes a huge amount of motivation and hard work to become any good at it. Sure you can learn how to do simple stuff without any serious interest, but to be beyond ordinary it takes enormous work and time and research and Joe Schlepp off the street is simply not going to do that.
If you want to hire people and teach them then you need to look for these things: enthusiasm for computers and programming, demonstrated willingness to learn, energy and effort. You should value energy and effort more highly than anything. Those are the raw ingredients for trainees, and people with those ingredients are far from "anyone".
- wdmeldon 11y agoMy first job hired me with zero programming experience because they thought this. I like to think I turned out ok, but I strongly disagree with the sentiment. A more accurate statement would be "You can train most people to be relatively competent at average programming tasks."
- gohrt 11y agoIndeed, there's simply no way that people who grew up in backwater regions like China, or India, could be competent at building software.
- andrewstuart 11y agoPeople who want to feel insulted always find ways to feel insulted. If you choose to read my comment that way then you are choosing to hear the message that you want to hear, which is a reflection of you and your personal issues. My comment in no way suggested that overseas developers are incompetent - in fact whether or not a developer is competent has little to do with where they live - although economic opportunity is part of the equation. Great programmers create themselves by hard work and that has nothing to do with location.
- TheOneTrueKyle 11y agoAnother case of hostility masked as objectivity on HN. You are entitled to your opinion, but it seems like you are justifying your position in life more so than providing anything of value to the conversation. I do agree with you however in that there is a difference between greatness and adequacy
- bad_user 11y agoYou know what the irony is? Us programmers thinking that "everyone can be a great programmer" is our preponderant liberal and very idealistic views showing. And we keep going around and shout that and other people believe it. And in turn we are being taken advantage of with long hours, unfair compensation for our contributions and the worse of it all? Ageism in our industry is rampant. I look at physicians, surgeons, accountants, lawyers and others with envy, because in those professions, the older you get, the more esteemed and valuable you are. We peak at 30.
- wlievens 11y agoPeak at thirty? You're depressing!
- kafkaesq 11y agoIn a sense, market worth of programmers does start to crest sharply by age 30 or 35, independent of intrinsic ability.
- aetherson 11y agoI'm not 100% sure what you mean by "market worth." Do you mean salary? Because if so, no. Do you mean something like "net value to company"? Then maybe. Another way to say that would be "you start to get paid what you're worth after 30 or 35."
- hiram112 11y agoI'm mid 30's and the salary cap is what I'm experiencing. Inversely, many of my friends in business, law, medical, etc. made less than I throughout their 20's and have now caught up, with potentials to earn far more. For example, the lawyers I know are now making partner in firms, the business majors getting percentages based on sales and earnings. I'm looking to become a consultant but the very idea of increasing pay with experience is foreign in the tech field, but standard in other professional trades. I believe offshoring, H1Bs, and lack of a professional association (AMA, bar, etc) is to blame.
- kafkaesq 11y agoFlat out dead wrong. Don't take things too literally. What he basically meant was "anyone with appropriate aptitude and intellectual maturity" -- like you yourself said later on, pretty much. Which may or may not be entirely correct, but is far from "dead wrong." BTW, please be careful about referring to foreigners, in any context, as "monkeys."
- sokoloff 11y agoParent may have edited the post (as I don't see "monkey" anywhere), but I frequently hear monkey used for any human (often fellow programmers) and have never read a racial or ethnic overtone into it and the usage has generally been to suggest that humans (of all sorts) aren't particularly different from monkeys. I just got back from an business trip spanning 3 cities and 5 flights. The self-loading cargo in the airports, jetways, and boarding the plane could easily have been described as monkeys. I was literally called a monkey by a colleague for absent-mindedly and needlessly blocking a sidewalk in the parking lot while waiting for someone to pay for parking. I took no offense, of course.
- andrewstuart 11y agoI did edit the post, despite the fact that the reference was towards management thinking about programmers as "monkeys" it appears it was being misinterpreted by skim-readers as overseas people being called monkeys. My point is that if you do not understand that programming is highly skilled work (and many companies think this) then you might think you can get anyone to do it for a similar outcome and therefore it is a commodity and therefore the only thing that matters is price.
- kafkaesq 11y agoRight, I understood the intended abstraction, after the 2nd or 3rd skim. Just that even analytical people tend to think "associationally" when they see certain keywords -- and one has to keep in mind that not too long ago, people in many of the countries that software development is frequently outsourced to were, in fact, thought of as monkeys, pretty much (or something on the human-monkey spectrum). So whenever I see associations like that creeping into my own writing, I try to dial it down.
- fsloth 11y ago"Everyone" here I think means the same as "anyone can be a great cook" in Ratatuille - it does not mean that anyone can learn to cook - but that a good programmer can arise from any background. My experience would support this. You need a mindset keen towards rigor, and motivation. Given those, and guidance, anyone can learn to program - at least in limited contexts.
- shepardrtc 11y agoI agree. My friend was a barista with a philosophy degree. But he had the intelligence, the rigor, and the desire to learn. All I had to do was point him in a couple of directions and he picked up programming very quickly on his own with no prior experience. In fact, I would say he's far better at it than me even after just a year or so. Mindset is the key.
- Bluestrike2 11y agoA lot of people joke about philosophy majors not being able to find jobs or make any money (the only people worse off are those who studied sociology :D), but that's not really true unless you're actually trying to become a philosophy professor. Then you're screwed. But aside from that, studying philosophy is a great way to hone your critical thinking skills, though of course it's not the only way. It's a lot more than just reading Plato and summarizing things, especially once you get beyond the intro-level courses. Obviously, I wouldn't recommend taking philosophy courses instead of CS, but they're an excellent compliment for programmers or pretty much any field. Programming isn't just about writing the code itself; in many ways, that's the easiest part. It's about identifying and solving problems, many of which aren't actually your problems, meaning you have to have the ability to step outside your own frame of reference to understand the problem in the first place and continue doing so in order to work up a solution. Even for a junior developer, those skills can be a huge boon.
- elcritch 11y agoGreat points, I was going to write almost the same thing. To build upon your last point, I'd argue that a solid (and rigorous!) philosophy education is in many ways better suited to building a sound logical problem solving mindset than much of the common core CS curriculum. Critical reasoning is much more valuable than just knowing Java or C++ syntax. Not to denigrate CS education, but rather to point out there is a lot more to learning to think in a way useful to programming complex systems than the current core of CS teaches. Especially in large (million line+) code-bases. Learning, say, Wittgenstein's philosophy regarding grammar and language [1] gives an interesting insight into how humans express ourselves and delves directly into the heart of modern programming, IMHO. Rarely do we software developers write low level algorithms anymore, but writing consistent and complex API's is crucial and shares more in common with be conversant with large volumes of philosophical treatises. Based on that, it makes sense many philosophy students would have successful careers – being able to reason and solve challenging problems is always key point in making good money. :) [1]: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wittgenstein/#Gra http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wittgenstein/#Gra
- Spooky23 11y agoWe overestimate how hard programming is. Very few jobs in industry on a proportional basis require the formal math or computer architecture that you get in a compsci program. I'm not a 10x programmer by any means, but I was able to write and sell non-trivial software in middle school, with little more than a pirated copy of Delphi and a book. Most of the difficulty that does exist has more to do with bad engineering practice and poor documentation than anything else.